Powell Emma, Woodfield Lorayne A, Nevill Alan M
School of Education, Newman University, Birmingham, UK.
School of Human Sciences, Newman University, Birmingham, UK.
Prev Med Rep. 2015 Nov 22;3:7-13. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2015.11.007. eCollection 2016 Jun.
To evaluate the effectiveness of a one-year teaching intervention to increase moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) during primary school physical education (PE).
A quasi-experimental, non-equivalent group design involving four classes from two primary schools in the West Midlands, UK. In March 2014 schools were selected through purposive sampling to match schools in terms of size and demographics (baseline, n = 111: post-intervention, n = 95); data were collected from children in school years 3 and 4 (aged 7 to 9 years). The intervention involved developing teacher effectiveness through the SHARP Principles Model which was grounded in the Self Determination Theory (SDT), the Social Ecological Model (SEM) and three key ingredients from the Behaviour Change Taxonomy (BCT). MVPA was assessed at baseline and four weeks post-intervention using the System for Observing Fitness and Instruction Time (SOFIT). Four individual teacher interviews were conducted with the intervention school, to explore teachers' perceptions of the intervention.
A two-way ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) indicated large interaction effect sizes for time spent in MVPA (F(1, 27) = 11.07, p = 0.003, ηp (2) = .316) and vigorous activity (VPA) (F = (1,27) = 8.557, p = .007, ηp (2) = .263). PA in the intervention school increased significantly whereas in the control school MVPA remained relatively constant and VPA decreased. The qualitative findings revealed two main emergent themes: a paradigm shift and teacher's developing pedagogy.
The intervention was effective in increasing MVPA in PE. Recommendations based on this evaluation would be for the SHARP Principles Model to be replicated and evaluated on a wider scale across a variety of contexts.
评估一项为期一年的教学干预措施在小学体育课程中增加中度至剧烈身体活动(MVPA)的有效性。
采用准实验、非等效组设计,涉及英国西米德兰兹郡两所小学的四个班级。2014年3月,通过目的抽样选择学校,以匹配学校的规模和人口统计学特征(基线时,n = 111;干预后,n = 95);从3年级和4年级(7至9岁)的儿童中收集数据。干预措施包括通过基于自我决定理论(SDT)、社会生态模型(SEM)和行为改变分类法(BCT)的三个关键要素的SHARP原则模型来提高教师效能。在基线和干预后四周,使用观察健身和教学时间系统(SOFIT)评估MVPA。对干预学校的四位教师进行了个别访谈,以探讨教师对干预措施的看法。
双向方差分析表明,在MVPA花费的时间(F(1, 27) = 11.07,p = 0.003,ηp(2) = 0.316)和剧烈活动(VPA)(F = (1,27) = 8.557,p = 0.007,ηp(2) = 0.263)方面存在较大的交互效应量。干预学校的身体活动显著增加,而对照学校的MVPA保持相对稳定,VPA则下降。定性研究结果揭示了两个主要的新出现主题:范式转变和教师教学方法的发展。
该干预措施在增加体育课程中的MVPA方面是有效的。基于此评估的建议是,SHARP原则模型应在更广泛的各种背景下进行复制和评估。