Arain Amir, Tammaa Maamoon, Chaudhary Faria, Gill Shazil, Yousuf Syed, Bangalore-Vittal Nandakumar, Singh Pradumna, Jabeen Shagufta, Ali Shahid, Song Yanna, Azar Nabil J
Department of Neurology, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, A-0118 Medical Center North, Nashville, TN 37232, USA.
Department of Neurology, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, A-0118 Medical Center North, Nashville, TN 37232, USA.
J Clin Neurosci. 2016 Jun;28:67-70. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2015.10.030. Epub 2016 Feb 6.
Psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) are a common cause of refractory seizures. Video-electroencephalographic (EEG) monitoring has allowed PNES to be effectively distinguished from epileptic seizures. Once the diagnosis of PNES is established, neurologists face the challenge of explaining it to patients. Patients may not always receive the diagnosis well. The aim of this study is to evaluate how effectively patients receive and perceive the diagnosis of PNES. This prospective study was conducted in an eight-bed epilepsy monitoring unit (EMU). Adult patients with newly confirmed PNES were included. After receiving written consent, a self-administered questionnaire was given to patients after the attending physician had communicated the diagnosis of PNES. A total of 75 patients were recruited. All patients had their typical seizures recorded on video-EEG (range 1-12, mean 2.18). Seventy patients were satisfied with the diagnosis of PNES. Nine patients did not agree that PNES has a psychological cause. Nineteen patients thought that the EMU doctors had no clue as to the cause of their seizures and 20 thought that there was no hope for a cure of their seizures. A significant number of patients with PNES feel that there is no hope for cure of their seizures. Thorough education about PNES, properly preparing patients before discussing the diagnosis of PNES, and preferably earlier diagnosis may prevent this miscommunication and result in better outcomes. A comprehensive approach including psychological counseling and psychiatric input, evaluation and treatment, in order to bring the illness from the subconscious to the conscious level, and effective follow-up may be helpful.
心理性非癫痫性发作(PNES)是难治性癫痫发作的常见原因。视频脑电图(EEG)监测已使PNES能够有效地与癫痫发作区分开来。一旦确立了PNES的诊断,神经科医生就面临着向患者解释该诊断的挑战。患者可能并不总是能很好地接受该诊断。本研究的目的是评估患者接受和理解PNES诊断的效果如何。这项前瞻性研究在一个有八张床位的癫痫监测单元(EMU)中进行。纳入新确诊为PNES的成年患者。在获得书面同意后,在主治医生告知患者PNES诊断后,向患者发放一份自行填写的问卷。共招募了75名患者。所有患者的典型发作均通过视频脑电图记录(范围为1 - 12次,平均2.18次)。70名患者对PNES的诊断感到满意。9名患者不认同PNES有心理原因。19名患者认为EMU的医生对其癫痫发作的原因毫无头绪,20名患者认为其癫痫发作没有治愈的希望。相当一部分PNES患者觉得他们的癫痫发作没有治愈的希望。对PNES进行全面教育、在讨论PNES诊断之前适当地让患者做好准备,最好能更早诊断,可能会避免这种沟通不畅并带来更好的结果。一种综合方法,包括心理咨询和精神科介入、评估和治疗,以便将疾病从潜意识层面带到意识层面,以及有效的随访可能会有所帮助。