Kunin Marina, Allen Amy R, Nicolas Caroline, Freed Gary L
Centre for Health Policy, Melbourne School of Population and Global Health, The University of Melbourne, 207 Bouverie Street, Carlton, Vic. 3053, Australia. Email: ;
Aust Health Rev. 2017 Mar;41(1):63-67. doi: 10.1071/AH15218.
Objective The aims of the present study were to determine the actual availability of private general paediatric appointments in the Melbourne metropolitan region for children with non-urgent chronic illnesses and the cost of such care. Methods A 'secret shopper' method was used. Telephone calls were made to a random sample of 47 private paediatric clinics. A trained research assistant posed as a parent, requesting the first available appointment with a specific paediatrician. Data regarding appointment availability, total potential charges and net charges after the Medicare rebate were collected. Results Appointments were available in 79% (n=37) of clinics, with 72% (n=34) able to offer an appointment with the requested general paediatrician. The number of days until available appointments varied from same day appointments to a wait of 124 days, with an average wait of 33 days. Of practices that provided information about the appointment cost (n=42), five bulk-billed for the consultation, whereas the remainder (n=37) were fee-paying clinics. The potential maximum charge for an initial consultation in the fee-paying clinics ranged from A$177 to A$430, with an average cost of A$279. The potential maximum out-of-pocket cost for patients ranged from A$40 to A$222, with an average out-of-pocket cost of A$128. Conclusions Private paediatric care in the Melbourne metropolitan region is generally available. The out-of-pocket cost of private paediatric out-patient care may present a potential economic barrier for some families. What is known about the topic? In Australia, out-of-pocket expenses for private specialist care are not covered by private health insurance. There are no data available on the actual cost of private paediatric consultations that are based on real-time assessments. Data collected in 1998 suggested that the average waiting time for a first standard consultation with a general paediatrician in a private room was 14.1 days. There are no recent empirical data on appointment availability and waiting time for appointments with general paediatricians in Australia. What does this paper add? There is high availability of paediatric consultations in the private sector. Waiting times for an appointment vary considerably from same day appointments to a wait of 124 days, with an average wait of 33 days. The cost of a private paediatric consultation in Australia to the patient is considerable, with an average potential maximum up-front charge for an initial consultation of A$279 and an average potential maximum out-of-pocket cost of A$128. What are the implications for practitioners? Data on the availability and cost of private paediatric consultations are imperative to formulate evidence-informed policy and better understand variations in the availability of public and private care.
目的 本研究旨在确定墨尔本大都市区为患有非紧急慢性病儿童提供的私立普通儿科预约的实际可及性以及此类护理的费用。方法 采用“秘密顾客”方法。随机拨打了47家私立儿科诊所的电话。一名经过培训的研究助理假扮家长,要求预约某位特定儿科医生的首个可用预约时段。收集了有关预约可及性、总潜在费用以及医疗保险回扣后的净费用的数据。结果 79%(n = 37)的诊所提供预约服务,其中72%(n = 34)能够提供与所要求的普通儿科医生的预约。直至有可用预约的天数从当天预约到等待124天不等,平均等待时间为33天。在提供预约费用信息的诊所中(n = 42),有5家诊所对会诊实行全额公费,其余(n = 37)为收费诊所。收费诊所初次会诊的潜在最高收费从177澳元到430澳元不等,平均费用为279澳元。患者潜在的最高自付费用从40澳元到222澳元不等,平均自付费用为128澳元。结论 墨尔本大都市区的私立儿科护理总体上是可及的。私立儿科门诊护理的自付费用可能对一些家庭构成潜在的经济障碍。关于该主题已知的情况是什么?在澳大利亚,私立专科护理的自付费用不在私人医疗保险范围内。目前尚无基于实时评估的私立儿科会诊实际费用的数据。1998年收集的数据表明,在私人房间与普通儿科医生进行首次标准会诊的平均等待时间为14.1天。目前尚无关于澳大利亚普通儿科医生预约可及性和等待时间的最新实证数据。本文补充了什么内容?私立部门的儿科会诊可及性较高。预约等待时间差异很大,从当天预约到等待124天不等,平均等待时间为33天。澳大利亚患者进行私立儿科会诊的费用相当可观,初次会诊的潜在最高前期收费平均为279澳元,潜在最高自付费用平均为128澳元。对从业者有何影响?私立儿科会诊的可及性和费用数据对于制定循证政策以及更好地理解公立和私立护理可及性的差异至关重要。