Soares Caio Belém Rodrigues Barros, Almeida Manuella Santos Carneiro, Lopes Patrícia de Medeiros Loureiro, Beltrão Ricardo Villar, Pontual Andrea dos Anjos, Ramos-Perez Flávia Maria de Moraes, Figueroa José Naral, Pontual Maria Luiza dos Anjos
Universidade Federal de Pernambuco, Recife, PE, Brazil.
Department of Clinical and Social Dentistry, Universidade Federal da Paraíba, Campina Grande, PB, Brazil.
Forensic Sci Int. 2016 May;262:183-9. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2016.03.030. Epub 2016 Mar 21.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the applicability of human identification parameters, established by Tatlisumak et al. (2007), by means of cone-beam computed tomography and extraoral radiographs of the frontal sinus region. From a total of 58 dry skulls, 26 were selected. Posteroanterior, profile cephalometric radiographs and cone-beam computed tomography images were acquired, adopting a specific method for reproducibility purposes. The images were evaluated by two examiners, previously calibrated, in a darkened environment and at two distinct sessions, with a minimum of 15 days between them. The characteristics of the frontal sinus were analyzed using the Cohen's kappa test, for categorical variables, and Lin's concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) for continuous variables. Acceptable values of inter method variability for the categorical variables were found, while same cannot be told for continuous variables. The parameters evaluated for the frontal sinus on extraoral radiographs and cone-beam computed tomographs were mostly concordant, with the exception of three. Categorical and discrete variables showed an intra- and interexaminer concordance ranging from good to perfect, and the quantitative continuous variables showed concordance ranging from moderate to excellent. The parameters examined are applicable and reproducible using multiplanar reconstructions of cone-beam computed tomography and extraoral radiographs of the frontal sinus.
本研究的目的是通过锥形束计算机断层扫描和额窦区域的口腔外X光片,评估Tatlisumak等人(2007年)建立的人类识别参数的适用性。在总共58个干燥颅骨中,挑选出26个。采用特定方法获取后前位、侧位头影测量X光片和锥形束计算机断层扫描图像,以确保可重复性。图像由两名预先校准的检查人员在暗环境中、两个不同的时间段进行评估,两次评估之间至少间隔15天。对于分类变量,使用Cohen's kappa检验分析额窦的特征;对于连续变量,使用Lin's一致性相关系数(CCC)进行分析。发现分类变量的方法间变异性值可接受,而连续变量则不然。在口腔外X光片和锥形束计算机断层扫描上评估的额窦参数大多一致,只有三个例外。分类和离散变量在检查者内部和检查者之间的一致性从良好到完美,定量连续变量的一致性从中等到优秀。所检查的参数通过锥形束计算机断层扫描的多平面重建和额窦的口腔外X光片是适用且可重复的。