Suppr超能文献

17至19世纪的医生及其患者

Doctors and Their Patients in the Seventeenth to Nineteenth Centuries.

作者信息

Baschin Marion, Dietrich-Daum Elisabeth, Ritzmann Iris

出版信息

Clio Med. 2016;96:39-70.

Abstract

How can these finings be interpreted in conclusion? Analysis has revealed firstly that, depending on the chosen period, the socio-geographical situation and the profile of the individual doctor's practice, the clientele varied widely in terms of gender, age and social rank. The consultation behaviour of men and women changed noticeably. Findings overall suggest that up until t8o the gender distribution varied in the individual practices. There was a trend for women to be overrepresented in urban practices during the earlier period. But in general, from the mid-nineteenth century they predominated - in towns as well as in the country in allopathic as well as homeopathic practices. The absence of children, which was bemoaned by many physicians, did not apply to the practices under investigation. On the contrary: the percentage is consistently high while older patients remained underrepresented right up until the end of the period under investigation, even though their proportion increased in the individual practices during the course of the nineteenth century In each of the nineteenth century practices investigated - and increasingly among the lower and middle classes - the physicians' services were used by several members of the same family. We have found no evidence to support the thesis that up until the nineteenth century academic physicians were mainly consulted by aristocratic or wealthy bourgeois patients. The theory probably applies only to early modern urban doctors. In the practices examined here, from the middle of the eighteenth century, patients from all social strata went to consult physicians. The participation of members of the lower classes or from an artisanal, (proto) industrial or agricultural background clearly increased over time 'despite ubiquitous economic and cultural barriers. That the annual numbers of consultations per physician increased - despite the growing number of physicians available - suggests that for economically disadvantaged social groups also, the consultation of learned physicians became more common: in towns from the first half of the nineteenth century and in the country from the middle of the century. In addition, the individual findings reveal that, prior to the introduction of statutory health insurance for salaried persons, patients of more secure social standing consulted a physician considerably more frequently in the course of the year than lower class patients. While the patient structure clearly changed around 1800, the relationship between physician and patient continued without major changes from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century. The therapeutic encounter up until the end of the investigated period can be summarized as a negotiation process. Patients were discerning in their choice of healer and did not refrain from using rival services. They sought help for unpleasant symptoms such as indigestion, pain or fever, and only rarely in cases of emergency Therapy was decided on after an exchange between a critical and autonomous client and the medical specialist who was generally willing to compromise. While the patient structure clearly changed around 1800, the relationship between physician and patient continued without major changes from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century. The therapeutic encounter up until the end of the investigated period can be summarized as a negotiation process. Patients were discerning in their choice of healer and did not refrain from using rival services. they sought help for unpleasant symptoms such as indigestion, pain or fever, and only rarely in cases of emergency. Therapy was decided on after an exchange between critical and autonomous client and the medical specialist who was generally willing to compromise.

摘要

总之,这些调查结果该如何解读呢?分析首先表明,根据所选时期、社会地理状况以及个体医生执业情况的不同,患者群体在性别、年龄和社会阶层方面差异很大。男性和女性的就诊行为有显著变化。总体研究结果表明,直到1800年,个体诊所中的性别分布各不相同。早期城市诊所中女性所占比例偏高。但总体而言,从19世纪中叶起,她们在城镇和乡村的对抗疗法及顺势疗法诊所中都占主导地位。许多医生哀叹的没有儿童患者的情况,并不适用于所调查的诊所。相反:儿童患者的比例一直很高,而老年患者直到调查期结束时所占比例仍然偏低,尽管在19世纪的过程中,他们在个体诊所中的比例有所增加。在所调查的19世纪的每个诊所中——并且在中下层阶级中越来越多——同一家族的几名成员都会使用医生的服务。我们没有找到证据支持这样的论点,即直到19世纪,学术医生的主要就诊者是贵族或富有的资产阶级患者。该理论可能仅适用于近代早期的城市医生。在这里所研究的诊所中,从18世纪中叶起,来自所有社会阶层的患者都会去咨询医生。尽管存在普遍的经济和文化障碍,但随着时间的推移,下层阶级或来自工匠、(早期)工业或农业背景的人的参与明显增加。每位医生的年度就诊人数增加了——尽管可用医生的数量也在增加——这表明,对于经济上处于不利地位的社会群体来说,咨询有学问的医生也变得更加普遍:在城镇是从19世纪上半叶开始,在乡村是从该世纪中叶开始。此外,个体研究结果表明,在为受薪人员引入法定健康保险之前,社会地位更稳固的患者在一年中咨询医生的频率明显高于下层阶级患者。虽然患者结构在1800年左右明显发生了变化,但从17世纪到19世纪,医患关系没有发生重大变化。直到调查期结束时的治疗过程可以概括为一个协商过程。患者在选择治疗师时很有辨别力,并不排斥使用其他竞争服务。他们会因消化不良、疼痛或发烧等不适症状寻求帮助,只有在紧急情况下才很少就诊。治疗方案是在挑剔且自主的患者与通常愿意妥协的医学专家交流后确定的。虽然患者结构在1800年左右明显发生了变化,但从17世纪到19世纪,医患关系没有发生重大变化。直到调查期结束时的治疗过程可以概括为一个协商过程。患者在选择治疗师时很有辨别力,并不排斥使用其他竞争服务。他们会因消化不良、疼痛或发烧等不适症状寻求帮助,只有在紧急情况下才很少就诊。治疗方案是在挑剔且自主的患者与通常愿意妥协的医学专家交流后确定的。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验