Choudhury Tahina, Robertson Will Dean, Finnigan Darryl S
J Environ Qual. 2016 May;45(3):796-802. doi: 10.2134/jeq2015.07.0380.
Woodchip filters have received attention in recent years for their ability to sustain denitrification activity across multiyear time frames. However, in some freshwater aquatic ecosystems, P rather than N is the nutrient considered most responsible for eutrophication. Previous studies have indicated that woodchip filters have limited ability to remove dissolved P, but in agricultural terrain, P export in watercourses is often dominated by particulate P (PP). Woodchip media, because of their high porosity and permeability and the surface roughness of the particles, could be effective for PP removal. In this study, we tested a woodchip filter for its ability to remove suspended sediment and associated PP at a farm in southern Ontario, Canada, where vegetable wash water with extremely high total suspended solids (TSS) was generated. The treatment system consisted of a 12.3-m concrete sedimentation tank and a slightly larger woodchip filter (16.1 m) installed in a subsurface trench. During 7 mo of full-scale operation, treating 10.8 m d, the filter system removed 71% of influent total P (TP) averaging 8.8 mg L and 99% of TSS averaging 5800 mg L, with most of the removal occurring in the tank and a lesser amount (6-16%) occurring in the woodchip filter. Almost all of the TP removal was associated with PP (91% removal) because dissolved P, averaging 1.5 mg L in the wash water, was little changed. Woodchip filters, when coupled with a solids settling tank, have the potential to provide high-capacity, low-maintenance treatment of suspended solids and associated particulate P in turbid waters.
近年来,木片过滤器因其能够在多年时间内维持反硝化活性而受到关注。然而,在一些淡水水生生态系统中,磷而非氮被认为是导致富营养化的主要营养物质。先前的研究表明,木片过滤器去除溶解磷的能力有限,但在农业区域,河道中的磷输出通常以颗粒态磷(PP)为主。木片介质由于其高孔隙率、高渗透性以及颗粒表面粗糙度,可能对去除颗粒态磷有效。在本研究中,我们在加拿大安大略省南部的一个农场测试了一个木片过滤器去除悬浮泥沙及相关颗粒态磷的能力,该农场产生的蔬菜清洗水总悬浮固体(TSS)含量极高。处理系统由一个12.3米的混凝土沉淀池和一个稍大的(16.1米)安装在地下沟渠中的木片过滤器组成。在为期7个月的满负荷运行期间,日处理量为10.8立方米,该过滤系统去除了平均浓度为8.8毫克/升的进水总磷(TP)的71%以及平均浓度为5800毫克/升的总悬浮固体的99%,大部分去除发生在沉淀池中,较少部分(6 - 16%)发生在木片过滤器中。几乎所有的总磷去除都与颗粒态磷有关(去除率为91%),因为清洗水中平均浓度为1.5毫克/升的溶解磷变化不大。木片过滤器与固体沉淀池相结合时,有潜力对浑浊水体中的悬浮固体及相关颗粒态磷进行高容量、低维护的处理。