van Dodewaard-de Jong Joyce M, Santegoets Saskia Jam, van de Ven Peter M, Versluis Jurjen, Verheul Henk M W, de Gruijl Tanja D, Gerritsen Winald R, van den Eertwegh Alfons J M
Department of Medical Oncology, VU University Medical Center , Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Department of Clinical Oncology, Leiden University Medical Center , Leiden, the Netherlands.
Oncoimmunology. 2015 Dec 21;5(4):e1105431. doi: 10.1080/2162402X.2015.1105431. eCollection 2016 Apr.
Previous vaccination studies in patients with castration-resistant prostate cancer (CRPC) showed improved survival without prolongation of progression-free survival (PFS). This might be explained by enhanced efficacy of subsequent therapies because of heightened immune status. We therefore evaluated the efficacy of chemotherapy in CRPC patients after immunotherapy. We retrospectively analyzed 28 patients who were treated with ipilimumab and GVAX, an allogeneic vaccine, and 21 patients who were randomized to GVAX or no vaccination. To study whether immune status was related to the efficacy of chemotherapy, frequencies of myeloid and lymphocyte subsets were determined. Of 28 patients treated with GVAX and ipilimumab, 23 patients received docetaxel and 13 patients mitoxantrone. Median PFS after docetaxel was 6.4 mo (range 0.8-11.2), while median PFS after mitoxantrone was markedly longer than expected (4.8 mo; range 1.4-13.7). High CD8ICOS Tcell/Treg and pDC/mMDSC ratios were associated with relatively long PFS after mitoxantrone, suggesting a correlation between activated immune status and benefit of mitoxantrone. Analysis of 21 patients, randomized to GVAX or not, revealed a median PFS after docetaxel of 9.9 mo for vaccinated patients and 7.1 mo for unvaccinated patients. Interestingly, PFS after mitoxantrone (n = 14) was significantly longer in vaccinated patients as compared to controls (5.9 vs. 1.6 mo, = 0.0048). In conclusion, mitoxantrone seems more effective in CRPC patients after immunotherapy, which may be related to the immune-stimulating effect of mitoxantrone in patients with heightened antitumor immunity. As this was a retrospective study with limited sample size, prospective studies are warranted to definitively show proof of principle.
既往针对去势抵抗性前列腺癌(CRPC)患者的疫苗接种研究显示,生存率有所提高,但无进展生存期(PFS)并未延长。这可能是由于免疫状态增强,后续治疗的疗效得到了提高。因此,我们评估了免疫治疗后CRPC患者化疗的疗效。我们回顾性分析了28例接受伊匹单抗和同种异体疫苗GVAX治疗的患者,以及21例随机接受GVAX或未接种疫苗的患者。为了研究免疫状态是否与化疗疗效相关,我们测定了髓系和淋巴细胞亚群的频率。在28例接受GVAX和伊匹单抗治疗的患者中,23例接受了多西他赛治疗,13例接受了米托蒽醌治疗。多西他赛后的中位PFS为6.4个月(范围0.8 - 11.2个月),而米托蒽醌后的中位PFS明显长于预期(4.8个月;范围1.4 - 13.7个月)。高CD8ICOS T细胞/Treg和pDC/mMDSC比值与米托蒽醌治疗后相对较长的PFS相关,提示激活的免疫状态与米托蒽醌的获益之间存在相关性。对21例随机接受或未接受GVAX治疗的患者进行分析,结果显示接种疫苗的患者多西他赛后的中位PFS为9.9个月,未接种疫苗的患者为7.1个月。有趣的是,与对照组相比,接种疫苗的患者米托蒽醌治疗后的PFS(n = 14)明显更长(5.9个月对1.6个月,P = 0.0048)。总之,米托蒽醌在免疫治疗后的CRPC患者中似乎更有效,这可能与米托蒽醌在抗肿瘤免疫力增强的患者中的免疫刺激作用有关。由于这是一项样本量有限的回顾性研究,因此有必要进行前瞻性研究以明确证明其原理。