Politiek Klaziena, Christoffers Wietske Andrea, Coenraads Pieter-Jan, Schuttelaar Marie-Louise Anna
Department of Dermatology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands.
Dermatol Ther. 2016 Sep;29(5):364-371. doi: 10.1111/dth.12362. Epub 2016 May 5.
Acitretin has been used off-label for years to treat chronic hand eczema, but acitretin is less often prescribed as alitretinoïne was approved. This study evaluates both retinoids in a daily practice cohort of patients with severe chronic hand eczema in terms of drug survival and reasons for discontinuation. Patients using alitretinoin or acitretin between 01-01-1994 and 01-08-2015 were included in this retrospective daily practice study and analyzed by Kaplan-Meier drug survival curves. Potential determinants were analyzed by Cox regression analyses. Ninety-five patients were treated with alitretinoin and 109 patients with acitretin. The main reasons for discontinuation were adverse events and cleared hand eczema, 29.5 and 27.4% in alitretinoin versus 43.1 and 23.9% in acitretin. Patients with hyperkeratotic hand eczema had most often a good effect of treatment: 68.3% in alitretinoin and 50.7% in acitretin treatment. The drug survival rates of alitretinoin and acitretin after 12, 24, 36, and 52 weeks were 69.3, 45.1, 19.6, 7.0% and 74.3, 45.5, 33.8, 23.2%, respectively. Alitretinoin and acitretin are effective treatment options for patients with hand eczema. However, both treatments were more effective in patients with hyperkeratotic hand eczema. Fewer patients discontinued alitretinoin compared with acitretin due to adverse events.
多年来,阿维A一直被用于治疗慢性手部湿疹的非适应证用药,但随着阿利维A酸的获批,阿维A的处方量减少。本研究在一个严重慢性手部湿疹患者的日常临床队列中,就药物留存率和停药原因对这两种维甲酸类药物进行了评估。1994年1月1日至2015年8月1日期间使用阿利维A酸或阿维A的患者被纳入这项回顾性日常临床研究,并通过Kaplan-Meier药物留存曲线进行分析。通过Cox回归分析对潜在决定因素进行分析。95例患者接受了阿利维A酸治疗,109例患者接受了阿维A治疗。停药的主要原因是不良事件和手部湿疹消退,阿利维A酸组分别为29.5%和27.4%,阿维A组分别为43.1%和23.9%。角化过度型手部湿疹患者的治疗效果通常较好:阿利维A酸治疗组为68.3%,阿维A治疗组为50.7%。阿利维A酸和阿维A在12周、24周、36周和52周后的药物留存率分别为69.3%、45.1%、19.6%、7.0%和74.3%、45.5%、33.8%、23.2%。阿利维A酸和阿维A是手部湿疹患者的有效治疗选择。然而,这两种治疗方法对角化过度型手部湿疹患者更有效。与阿维A相比,因不良事件停药的阿利维A酸患者较少。