Lockhart Nicole C, Smith Anna M, Carithers Latarsha J, Weil Carol J
IRB. 2016 Mar-Apr;38(2):1-7.
The Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) project aims to study human gene expression and regulation in multiple tissues from individual post-mortem biospecimen donors. This case report involves GTEx donors who were discovered after biospecimen collection to have been the recipients of solid organ or tissue transplants for therapeutic purposes. This scenario prompted us to consider whether authorization from the GTEx research donor’s next of kin was legally and ethically acceptable to allow genomic research on tissue originally derived from a therapeutic organ donor. The outcome of the case was to withdraw the tissue from both the GTEx study and future research use. Given the complexity of the system governing organ and tissue donation in the U.S., more research is warranted to address some of the legal and ethical issues raised by this and related cases.
基因型-组织表达(GTEx)项目旨在研究来自个体尸检生物样本捐赠者的多个组织中的人类基因表达和调控。本病例报告涉及一些GTEx捐赠者,他们在生物样本采集后被发现曾接受过用于治疗目的的实体器官或组织移植。这种情况促使我们思考,对于原本来自治疗性器官捐赠者的组织进行基因组研究,获得GTEx研究捐赠者近亲的授权在法律和伦理上是否可接受。该病例的结果是将该组织从GTEx研究及未来研究用途中撤出。鉴于美国器官和组织捐赠管理系统的复杂性,有必要开展更多研究,以解决此类及相关案例引发的一些法律和伦理问题。