Haseeb Abdul, Bilal Muhammad, Ansari M Ahmed, Raheem Ahmed, Khan Aleena, Arshad Mohammad Hussham, Motiani Vanita, Akhtar Muhammad Shahzeb
Faculty, Department of Medicine, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences , Karachi, Pakistan .
Faculty, Department of Medicine, Medical College, Aga Khan University Hospital , Karachi, Pakistan .
J Clin Diagn Res. 2016 Apr;10(4):LC15-9. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2016/17419.7647. Epub 2016 Apr 1.
Equipping students with skills in medical research should be an integral part of medical education systems. This study is designed to gauge the difference in knowledge and attitudes towards health research between two sets of undergraduate medical students; those enrolled in the new Problem Based Learning (PBL) education system versus those of the conventional Lecture Based Learning (LBL) curricula.
From the 4(th) and 5(th) years of medical university students, 90 participants were recruited from the Aga Khan University (PBL group) and Dow University of Health Sciences (LBL group) and were presented with structured and pre-validated questionnaire. Responses obtained for knowledge and attitudes of each group were recorded on a scale and graduated in percentages to be compared statistically for differences to identify the effectiveness of each curriculum.
The score on the knowledge scale for the PBL group was found to be 44.77% against the 31.55% of the LBL students (p-value<0.001). Furthermore, the mean attitude score of AKU students was 72.22% as opposed to the 56.11% of the DUHS participants (p-value<0.001).
The PBL group achieved significantly higher scores in all aspects than the LBL group, showing healthier attitudes towards health science research along with better knowledge. Hence, the apparent positive influence of PBL curricula on attitudes towards research may be helpful in improving research output of medical students in Pakistan.
培养学生的医学研究技能应成为医学教育体系不可或缺的一部分。本研究旨在衡量两组本科医学生在健康研究知识和态度方面的差异;一组是采用新的基于问题的学习(PBL)教育体系的学生,另一组是传统的基于讲座的学习(LBL)课程体系的学生。
从医学院校的四年级和五年级学生中,招募了90名参与者,他们分别来自阿迦汗大学(PBL组)和道健康科学大学(LBL组),并向他们发放了经过结构化且预先验证的问卷。记录每组学生在知识和态度方面的回答,并进行评分,以百分比表示,以便进行统计学比较,以确定每种课程体系的有效性。
发现PBL组在知识量表上的得分是44.77%,而LBL组学生的得分是31.55%(p值<0.001)。此外,阿迦汗大学学生的平均态度得分是72.22%,而道健康科学大学参与者的得分是56.11%(p值<0.001)。
PBL组在各个方面的得分均显著高于LBL组,表明对健康科学研究的态度更积极,知识掌握得更好。因此,PBL课程体系对研究态度的明显积极影响可能有助于提高巴基斯坦医学生的研究产出。