White Leigh, Stockwell T, Hartnell N, Hennessy M, Mullan J
Faculty of Science, Medicine and Health, School of Medicine, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, NSW, 2522, Australia.
J Orthop Traumatol. 2016 Dec;17(4):333-338. doi: 10.1007/s10195-016-0411-1. Epub 2016 May 27.
Difficulties in kneeling, one of the poorest scoring functional outcomes post total knee arthroplasty (TKA),have been attributed to a lack of patient education. This is the first study to investigate specific factors affecting a patient's perceived ability to kneel post TKA, following exposure to a preoperative kneeling education session.
A cross-sectional study was conducted following TKA with patients who had been educated about kneeling prior to the operation. Patients completed kneeling questionnaires at 6 (n = 115) and 12 (n = 82) months post TKA. In addition to the 12-month kneeling questionnaire, patients also completed the Oxford knee score (OKS) survey.
Seventy-two percent of patients perceived they could kneel at 12 months post TKA. Overall, pain and discomfort were the most common factors deterring patients from kneeling. Perceived kneeling ability was the poorest scored outcome on the OKS with patients reporting mild to moderate difficulty with this task. Kneeling scores were strongly correlated with overall knee function scores (R = 0.70), strongly correlated with pain scores (R = 0.45) and weakly correlated with knee stability scores (R = 0.29). When asked about other factors preventing kneeling other than pain or discomfort, 75 % had reasons unrelated to the knee or TKA. The most common reason was 'problems with the other knee' (n = 19).
Patients in this study were provided with education regarding their kneeling ability post TKA, yet still experienced limitations in perceived kneeling ability postoperatively. Contrary to previous research, our study suggests that factors other than patient education affect a patient's perceived kneeling ability post TKA.
跪姿困难是全膝关节置换术(TKA)后功能评分最差的结果之一,这被认为是由于缺乏患者教育。这是第一项研究,旨在调查在接受术前跪姿教育后,影响患者TKA术后跪姿感知能力的具体因素。
对接受TKA手术且术前接受过跪姿教育的患者进行了一项横断面研究。患者在TKA术后6个月(n = 115)和12个月(n = 82)完成跪姿问卷调查。除了12个月的跪姿问卷外,患者还完成了牛津膝关节评分(OKS)调查。
72%的患者认为他们在TKA术后12个月能够跪姿。总体而言,疼痛和不适是阻碍患者跪姿的最常见因素。在OKS中,跪姿感知能力是评分最差的结果,患者报告在这项任务中存在轻度至中度困难。跪姿评分与整体膝关节功能评分密切相关(R = 0.70),与疼痛评分密切相关(R = 0.45),与膝关节稳定性评分弱相关(R = 0.29)。当被问及除疼痛或不适之外的其他阻碍跪姿的因素时,75%的患者有与膝关节或TKA无关的原因。最常见的原因是“另一个膝关节有问题”(n = 19)。
本研究中的患者接受了关于TKA术后跪姿能力的教育,但术后跪姿感知能力仍存在局限性。与先前的研究相反,我们的研究表明,除患者教育外,其他因素也会影响患者TKA术后的跪姿感知能力。