Flores Glenn, Lin Hua, Walker Candy, Lee Michael, Currie Janet M, Allgeyer Rick, Fierro Marco, Henry Monica, Portillo Alberto, Massey Kenneth
Medica Research Institute, Minnetonka, Minnesota;
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas;
Pediatrics. 2016 Apr;137(4). doi: 10.1542/peds.2015-3519. Epub 2016 Mar 17.
Six million US children are uninsured, despite two-thirds being eligible for Medicaid/Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and minority children are at especially high risk. The most effective way to insure uninsured children, however, is unclear.
We conducted a randomized trial of the effects of parent mentors (PMs) on insuring uninsured minority children. PMs were experienced parents with ≥1 Medicaid/CHIP-covered child who received 2 days of training, then assisted families for 1 year with insurance applications, retaining coverage, medical homes, and social needs; controls received traditional Medicaid/CHIP outreach. The primary outcome was obtaining insurance 1 year post-enrollment.
We enrolled 237 participants (114 controls; 123 in PM group). PMs were more effective (P< .05 for all comparisons) than traditional methods in insuring children (95% vs 68%), and achieving faster coverage (median = 62 vs 140 days), high parental satisfaction (84% vs 62%), and coverage renewal (85% vs 60%). PM children were less likely to have no primary care provider (15% vs 39%), problems getting specialty care (11% vs 46%), unmet preventive (4% vs 22%) or dental (18% vs 31%) care needs, dissatisfaction with doctors (6% vs 16%), and needed additional income for medical expenses (6% vs 13%). Two years post-PM cessation, more PM children were insured (100% vs 76%). PMs cost $53.05 per child per month, but saved $6045.22 per child insured per year.
PMs are more effective than traditional Medicaid/CHIP methods in insuring uninsured minority children, improving health care access, and achieving parental satisfaction, but are inexpensive and highly cost-effective.
尽管三分之二的美国儿童符合医疗补助/儿童健康保险计划(CHIP)的资格,但仍有600万儿童未参保,少数族裔儿童面临的风险尤其高。然而,为未参保儿童提供保险的最有效方式尚不清楚。
我们进行了一项关于家长导师(PMs)对未参保少数族裔儿童参保影响的随机试验。家长导师是有≥1名受医疗补助/CHIP覆盖儿童的经验丰富的家长,他们接受了2天的培训,然后在保险申请、维持保险覆盖、医疗之家和社会需求方面为家庭提供1年的协助;对照组接受传统的医疗补助/CHIP宣传推广。主要结局是登记入学1年后获得保险。
我们招募了237名参与者(114名对照组;123名家长导师组)。在为儿童提供保险方面(95%对68%),家长导师比传统方法更有效(所有比较P<0.05);在实现更快的保险覆盖方面(中位数=62天对140天)、更高的家长满意度方面(84%对62%)以及续保方面(85%对60%)也是如此。接受家长导师帮助的儿童不太可能没有初级保健提供者(15%对39%)、在获得专科护理方面存在问题(11%对46%)、有未满足的预防(4%对22%)或牙科(18%对31%)护理需求、对医生不满意(6%对16%)以及需要额外收入支付医疗费用(6%对13%)。在家长导师停止服务两年后,更多接受家长导师帮助的儿童获得了保险(100%对76%)。家长导师每月每个儿童的成本为53.05美元,但每年为每个参保儿童节省6045.22美元。
在为未参保的少数族裔儿童提供保险、改善医疗保健可及性以及实现家长满意度方面,家长导师比传统的医疗补助/CHIP方法更有效,而且成本低廉且具有很高的成本效益。