Matsumoto Kenji, Komukai Jun, Tsuda Yuko, Furukawa Kanae, Saito Kazumi, Hirota Satoshi, Koda Shinichi, Kasai Sachi, Shimouchi Akira
Kekkaku. 2016 Feb;91(2):45-8.
QuantiFERON® TB-Gold In-Tube (3G) testing was performed on tuberculosis-positive index cases and their contacts. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between 3G test results and the subsequent development of tuberculosis, and to identify effective strategies to prevent the onset of tuberculosis.
Index cases and their contacts were subjected to 3G testing in a contact investigation in Osaka City in 2011-2012. For index cases, sputum smears were tested, and the infecting organism was identified. For the contacts, the following information was collected: age, results of 3G testing, presence or absence of latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) treatment, and onset of tuberculosis disease within 2 years of follow-up from the last contact with the index cases.
(1) There were 830 index cases, including 774 subjects with pulmonary tuberculosis (93.3%) and 3 with laryngeal tuberculosis (0.4%). From sputum smear tests, 726 patients (87.5%) were determined to be 3G positive, and 83 (10.0%) were determined to be 3G negative. (2) In total, 2,644 contacts were subjected to 3G testing. Of these, 2,072 patients (78.4%) tested negative, 196 (7.4%) showed an equivocal result, and 375 (14.2%) tested positive. Their mean ages were 33.7, 38.0, and 38.8 years, respectively, showing significant differences in tuberculosis status according to age (P < 0.001). (3) Among the 2,072 3G-negative contacts, tuberculosis developed in 2 (0.1%) of 2063. None of these contacts was treated for LTBI. Among the 375 3G-positive contacts, tuberculosis developed in 36 (36.0%) of 100 subjects that were not LTBI treated, while tuberculosis developed in 3 (1.1 %) of 275 subjects that were LTBI treated. A significant difference in the incidence of tuberculosis between treated and untreated 3G-positive contacts was observed (P < 0.001).
Tuberculosis developed in a high proportion of 3G-positive contacts that were not LTBI treated, suggesting the need for preventive management of 3G-positive contacts.
对结核阳性的索引病例及其接触者进行管内QuantiFERON® TB-金标(3G)检测。本研究的目的是评估3G检测结果与后续结核病发病之间的关系,并确定预防结核病发病的有效策略。
2011年至2012年在大阪市的一次接触者调查中,对索引病例及其接触者进行了3G检测。对于索引病例,进行痰涂片检测,并鉴定感染病原体。对于接触者,收集以下信息:年龄、3G检测结果、是否接受潜伏性结核感染(LTBI)治疗以及自最后一次与索引病例接触后2年内结核病发病情况。
(1)共有830例索引病例,其中774例为肺结核患者(93.3%),3例为喉结核患者(0.4%)。通过痰涂片检测,726例患者(87.5%)被判定为3G阳性,而83例(10.0%)被判定为3G阴性。(2)总共有2644名接触者接受了3G检测。其中,2072例患者(78.4%)检测为阴性,196例(7.4%)结果不明确,375例(14.2%)检测为阳性。他们的平均年龄分别为33.7岁、38.0岁和38.8岁,显示出根据年龄在结核病状态上存在显著差异(P<0.001)。(3)在2072例3G阴性的接触者中,2063例中有2例(0.1%)发生了结核病。这些接触者均未接受LTBI治疗。在375例3G阳性的接触者中,100例未接受LTBI治疗的受试者中有36例(36.0%)发生了结核病,而275例接受LTBI治疗的受试者中有3例(1.1%)发生了结核病。观察到接受治疗和未接受治疗的3G阳性接触者之间结核病发病率存在显著差异(P<0.001)。
在未接受LTBI治疗的3G阳性接触者中,结核病发病率较高,这表明需要对3G阳性接触者进行预防性管理。