Schlieve Thomas, Heidel R Eric, Carlson Eric R
Oral/Head and Neck Oncologic Surgery Fellow, University of Tennessee Medical Center, Knoxville, TN.
Assistant Professor of Biostatistics, Department of Surgery, Office of Medical Education, Research, and Development, University of Tennessee Graduate School of Medicine, Knoxville, TN.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2016 Dec;74(12):2515-2520. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2016.05.009. Epub 2016 May 20.
The purpose of the present study was to determine the rate of second primary head and neck cancer development among patients with a primary cancer diagnosed outside the head and neck region, to present the clinical characteristics of this population, and to determine whether any variables are associated with survival.
We designed a case series based on a sample of patients diagnosed with head and neck cancer who had previously been diagnosed with cancer located outside the head and neck region. The primary predictor variable was a diagnosis of cancer outside the head and neck region. The primary outcome variable was the diagnosis of a second cancer in the head and neck region. χ Goodness-of-fit tests were used to test for differences between the observed and expected rates.
A total of 19,406 cancers were diagnosed at the University of Tennessee Cancer Institute during the study period from July 1, 2004 to June 30, 2014. The rate of second primary head and neck cancer among patients with a non-head and neck primary cancer was 0.2%. These 40 cancers occurred among a total of 849 head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) cases (5%) diagnosed during the study period. The most common location for a second primary HNSCC was the gingiva (27.5%), followed by the oral tongue (17.5%). Significantly more gingival cancers were diagnosed than expected (P < .001) and significantly fewer tongue cancers than expected (P = .01). The most common primary cancer was prostate (27.5%), followed by breast (25%). The median survival was 28.5 months after the second primary diagnosis. A nonsignificant effect was found for age (P = .30), tobacco use (P = .12), gender (P = .60), TNM stage (P = .29), and treatment protocol (P = .96) on survival.
The development of a second primary HNSCC in a population of patients with non-head and neck primary cancers is associated with decreased overall survival. The most common presentation of a second primary HNSCC in our study was in the gingiva and the most common primary cancer was in the prostate. Clinicians should consider the increased proportion of gingival cancers in this population when examining patients and be aware of the decrease in overall survival.
本研究旨在确定头颈部以外区域诊断为原发性癌症的患者中,第二原发性头颈部癌症的发生几率,呈现该人群的临床特征,并确定是否有任何变量与生存率相关。
我们基于先前被诊断为头颈部以外区域癌症的头颈部癌症患者样本设计了一个病例系列。主要预测变量是头颈部以外区域的癌症诊断。主要结局变量是头颈部区域的第二种癌症诊断。采用χ拟合优度检验来检验观察率与预期率之间的差异。
在2004年7月1日至2014年6月30日的研究期间,田纳西大学癌症研究所共诊断出19406例癌症。非头颈部原发性癌症患者中第二原发性头颈部癌症的发生率为0.2%。这40例癌症发生在研究期间诊断出的849例头颈部鳞状细胞癌(HNSCC)病例中(5%)。第二原发性HNSCC最常见的部位是牙龈(27.5%),其次是舌体(17.5%)。诊断出的牙龈癌明显多于预期(P <.001),舌癌明显少于预期(P =.01)。最常见的原发性癌症是前列腺癌(27.5%),其次是乳腺癌(25%)。第二次原发性诊断后的中位生存期为28.5个月。年龄(P =.30)、吸烟情况(P =.12)、性别(P =.60)、TNM分期(P =.29)和治疗方案(P =.96)对生存率无显著影响。
非头颈部原发性癌症患者中第二原发性HNSCC的发生与总生存率降低相关。在我们的研究中,第二原发性HNSCC最常见的表现部位是牙龈,最常见的原发性癌症是前列腺癌。临床医生在检查患者时应考虑该人群中牙龈癌比例的增加,并意识到总生存率的降低。