Oh Pok-Ja, Kim Soo Hyun
Sahmyook University.
Inha University.
Oncol Nurs Forum. 2016 Jul 1;43(4):468-79. doi: 10.1188/16.ONF.468-479.
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effects of expressive writing (EW) interventions in patients with cancer. .
DATA SOURCES: Electronic databases searched included both international and Korean databases through January 2015. .
DATA SYNTHESIS: Of the 20 trials that met the eligibility criteria of this review, a meta-analysis was conducted of 14 articles involving 13 randomized and 1 nonrandomized trials with 1,718 patients with cancer. EW interventions were compared with a neutral writing intervention or usual care (no writing). A significant small effect was noted on relieving cancer symptoms; however, the effects on psychological and cognitive outcomes were not significant. When subgroup analysis by control condition was performed, a significant effect on health-related quality of life was found between the EW intervention group and the usual care group. .
CONCLUSIONS: EW had significant small effects only on cancer symptoms. The findings suggest that the traditional EW intervention protocol may need to be intensified to confirm its effect on patients with cancer. .
Current evidence for EW as a nursing intervention for improving physical, psychological, and cognitive outcomes among patients with cancer is promising, but not conclusive.
目的/目标:评估表达性写作(EW)干预对癌症患者的影响。
检索的电子数据库包括截至2015年1月的国际数据库和韩国数据库。
在符合本综述纳入标准的20项试验中,对14篇文章进行了荟萃分析,这些文章涉及13项随机试验和1项非随机试验,共1718例癌症患者。将EW干预与中性写作干预或常规护理(无写作)进行比较。结果发现EW干预在缓解癌症症状方面有显著的微小效果;然而,对心理和认知结果的影响并不显著。在按对照条件进行亚组分析时,发现EW干预组和常规护理组在与健康相关的生活质量方面有显著差异。
EW仅对癌症症状有显著的微小效果。研究结果表明,可能需要强化传统的EW干预方案以证实其对癌症患者的效果。
目前关于EW作为一种护理干预措施改善癌症患者身体、心理和认知结果的证据很有前景,但尚无定论。