Department of Emergency Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.
Union of Medical Care and Relief Organizations, Paris, France.
JAMA Surg. 2016 Sep 1;151(9):815-22. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2016.1297.
The Syrian civil war has resulted in large-scale devastation of Syria's health infrastructure along with widespread injuries and death from trauma. The capacity of Syrian trauma hospitals is not well characterized. Data are needed to allocate resources for trauma care to the population remaining in Syria.
To identify the number of trauma hospitals operating in Syria and to delineate their capacities.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: From February 1 to March 31, 2015, a nationwide survey of 94 trauma hospitals was conducted inside Syria, representing a coverage rate of 69% to 93% of reported hospitals in nongovernment controlled areas.
Identification and geocoding of trauma and essential surgical services in Syria.
Although 86 hospitals (91%) reported capacity to perform emergency surgery, 1 in 6 hospitals (16%) reported having no inpatient ward for patients after surgery. Sixty-three hospitals (70%) could transfuse whole blood but only 7 (7.4%) could separate and bank blood products. Seventy-one hospitals (76%) had any pharmacy services. Only 10 (11%) could provide renal replacement therapy, and only 18 (20%) provided any form of rehabilitative services. Syrian hospitals are isolated, with 24 (26%) relying on smuggling routes to refer patients to other hospitals and 47 hospitals (50%) reporting domestic supply lines that were never open or open less than daily. There were 538 surgeons, 378 physicians, and 1444 nurses identified in this survey, yielding a nurse to physician ratio of 1.8:1. Only 74 hospitals (79%) reported any salary support for staff, and 84 (89%) reported material support. There is an unmet need for biomedical engineering support in Syrian trauma hospitals, with 12 fixed x-ray machines (23%), 11 portable x-ray machines (13%), 13 computed tomographic scanners (22%), 21 adult (21%) and 5 pediatric (19%) ventilators, 14 anesthesia machines (10%), and 116 oxygen cylinders (15%) not functional. No functioning computed tomographic scanners remain in Aleppo, and 95 oxygen cylinders (42%) in rural Damascus are not functioning despite the high density of hospitals and patients in both provinces.
Syrian trauma hospitals operate in the Syrian civil war under severe material and human resource constraints. Attention must be paid to providing biomedical engineering support and to directing resources to currently unsupported and geographically isolated critical access surgical hospitals.
叙利亚内战导致叙利亚卫生基础设施大规模遭到破坏,同时因创伤造成大量人员伤亡。叙利亚创伤医院的能力尚未得到充分描述。需要数据来为叙利亚境内剩余人口分配创伤护理资源。
确定在叙利亚运营的创伤医院数量,并划定其能力范围。
设计、地点和参与者:2015 年 2 月 1 日至 3 月 31 日,在叙利亚境内对 94 家创伤医院进行了一项全国范围的调查,代表了在非政府控制地区报告的医院中有 69%至 93%的覆盖范围。
确定和地理定位叙利亚的创伤和基本外科服务。
尽管 86 家医院(91%)报告有能力进行急诊手术,但1/6 的医院(16%)报告称手术后没有为患者提供住院病房。63 家医院(70%)可以输全血,但只有 7 家(7.4%)可以分离和储存血液制品。71 家医院(76%)设有任何药房服务。只有 10 家(11%)能够提供肾脏替代治疗,只有 18 家(20%)提供任何形式的康复服务。叙利亚医院是孤立的,有 24 家(26%)依靠走私路线将患者转介到其他医院,47 家医院(50%)报告国内供应线从未开放或每天开放不到一次。本次调查共确定了 538 名外科医生、378 名医生和 1444 名护士,护士与医生的比例为 1.8:1。只有 74 家(79%)医院报告对员工有任何工资支持,84 家(89%)报告有物资支持。叙利亚创伤医院急需生物医学工程支持,有 12 台固定 X 光机(23%)、11 台便携式 X 光机(13%)、13 台计算机断层扫描机(22%)、21 台成人(21%)和 5 台儿科(19%)呼吸机、14 台麻醉机(10%)和 116 个氧气罐(15%)无法正常工作。阿勒颇没有功能正常的计算机断层扫描机,尽管大马士革农村省的医院和患者密度都很高,但仍有 95 个氧气罐(42%)无法正常工作。
叙利亚创伤医院在叙利亚内战期间严重缺乏物质和人力资源。必须注意提供生物医学工程支持,并将资源导向目前未得到支持且地理位置偏远的关键获取手术医院。