Department of Thoracic Surgery, Kameda Medical Center, Chiba, Japan.
Department of Thoracic Surgery, Kameda Medical Center, Chiba, Japan.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2016 Sep;152(3):747-53. doi: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2016.05.059. Epub 2016 Jun 5.
Segmentectomy includes numerous kinds of procedures that may result in decreased postoperative pulmonary function. This causes controversy regarding the functional advantage of segmentectomy over lobectomy. To clarify the difference between the procedures, systemic and regional pulmonary functions of the resected segments must be examined.
Pulmonary function tests and lung perfusion single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) were prospectively conducted before and after segmentectomy in 117 patients who were divided into groups based on resection of <2 segments (n = 83), ≥2 segments (n = 20), and left upper division (LUD) (n = 14). Left upper lobectomy (n = 13) was used as a control for the LUD group. Forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) of segment and lobe were measured from a fusion image of SPECT and computed tomography.
Percentage of postoperative/preoperative pulmonary function was the highest in the <2 segments group (97% ± 10%), which was followed by the ≥2 segments group (90% ± 9%), LUD group (84% ± 7%), and left upper lobectomy group (83% ± 7%), and the differences between the segmentectomy groups were significant (P < .001-.03), although there was no difference between the LUD and lobectomy groups. Whereas actual FEV1 of preserved lobes were significantly lower than the predicted value in all segmentectomy groups (P < .001), the percentage of actual/predicted value in the LUD group (43% ± 19%) was significantly lower than those in the <2 (72% ± 23%) and ≥2 segments (68% ± 30%) groups (P < .001 and P = .02, respectively).
Segmentectomy decreased the pulmonary function with increasing number of resected segments. LUD segmentectomy decreased both systemic and lobar function significantly due to not only large resection, but also marked depression of the preserved lobe, resulting in similar decrease as lobectomy.
肺段切除术包括多种术式,可能导致术后肺功能下降。这使得肺段切除术比肺叶切除术具有功能优势的观点产生了争议。为了明确这些术式之间的区别,必须检查切除段的系统性和区域性肺功能。
对 117 例患者进行了前瞻性的肺功能检查和肺灌注单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)检查,这些患者根据切除的肺段数分为<2 个肺段(n=83)、≥2 个肺段(n=20)和左上叶(LUD)(n=14)。左肺上叶切除术(n=13)被用作 LUD 组的对照。从 SPECT 和计算机断层扫描的融合图像中测量 SPECT 和计算机断层扫描的 1 秒用力呼气量(FEV1)。
术后/术前肺功能百分比在<2 个肺段组最高(97%±10%),其次是≥2 个肺段组(90%±9%)、LUD 组(84%±7%)和左肺上叶切除术组(83%±7%),且段切除术组之间的差异具有统计学意义(P<.001-.03),尽管 LUD 组与肺叶切除术组之间无差异。尽管所有段切除术组的保留肺叶的实际 FEV1 均显著低于预测值(P<.001),但 LUD 组(43%±19%)的实际/预测值百分比明显低于<2 个(72%±23%)和≥2 个肺段(68%±30%)组(P<.001 和 P=.02)。
随着切除肺段数的增加,肺段切除术降低了肺功能。LUD 肺段切除术不仅由于大范围切除,而且由于保留肺叶明显受抑,导致系统性和区域性肺功能明显下降,导致与肺叶切除术相似的下降。