Berlingeri M, Gallucci M, Danelli L, Forgiarini M, Sberna M, Paulesu E
Department of Humanistic Studies (DISTUM), University of Urbino Carlo Bo, Urbino, Italy; NeuroMi, Milan Center for Neuroscience, Italy.
Psychology Department, University of Milano-Bicocca, Milano, Italy; NeuroMi, Milan Center for Neuroscience, Italy.
Neuroscience. 2016 Sep 22;332:231-41. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroscience.2016.06.048. Epub 2016 Jul 1.
The ability to share feelings with those of someone in pain is affected by the racial difference between the target and the onlooker. A differential empathic activation for race (DEAR effect) in favor of in-group members has been documented in the brain pain matrix. However, we are also capable of unbiased responses that manifest politically correct behaviors toward people of a different race. To address the neurofunctional signatures underlying both the DEAR effect and the manifestation of politically correct behaviors, we scanned with fMRI Caucasian participants while watching African or Caucasian actors touched by either a rubber eraser or a needle. Participants were instructed to empathize with the actors during the video presentation (stimulus phase) and to explicitly judge the pain level experienced by the actors (response phase). During the stimulus phase, we found a typical DEAR effect within the pain-matrix. This effect correlated with the level of implicit racial bias as measured by the IAT. On the other hand, during the response phase a significant out-group specific DEAR effect emerged in the prefrontal cortices. This latter effect was coupled with a revealing behavioral pattern: while the magnitude of the painful experience attributed to Caucasians and Africans was the same, our participants were significantly slower when judging the pain experience of the African actors. We propose a model that logically integrates these two contrasting forces at the neurobiological and behavioral level.
与处于痛苦中的人分享感受的能力会受到目标对象与旁观者之间种族差异的影响。大脑疼痛矩阵中已记录到一种有利于内群体成员的种族差异共情激活(DEAR效应)。然而,我们也能够做出公正的反应,表现出对不同种族的人符合政治正确的行为。为了探究DEAR效应和政治正确行为表现背后的神经功能特征,我们在白人参与者观看被橡皮或针触碰的非洲或白人演员时,用功能磁共振成像(fMRI)对他们进行扫描。在视频呈现期间(刺激阶段),要求参与者对演员产生共情,并在视频结束后(反应阶段)明确判断演员所经历的疼痛程度。在刺激阶段,我们在疼痛矩阵中发现了典型的DEAR效应。这种效应与通过内隐联想测验(IAT)测量的内隐种族偏见程度相关。另一方面,在反应阶段,前额叶皮层出现了显著的外群体特异性DEAR效应。后一种效应伴随着一种明显的行为模式:虽然参与者认为白人和非洲人所经历的痛苦程度相同,但在判断非洲演员的疼痛体验时明显较慢。我们提出了一个模型,在神经生物学和行为层面上逻辑地整合了这两种相互矛盾的力量。