Mooney LaVerne A, Fay Lorna
Pfizer Medical, Pfizer Inc, New York, New York, USA.
BMJ Open. 2016 Jul 18;6(7):e012362. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-012362.
To estimate the proportion of Pfizer-sponsored clinical trials that completed in 2010 and are published as manuscripts in the peer-reviewed literature, and to assess the manuscript development history.
Retrospective, cross-sectional analysis.
Clinical trials registered in ClinicalTrials.gov that completed in 2010 for approved, Pfizer prescription products in patients or vaccines in healthy participants.
The proportion of studies for which the primary outcome(s) was published and the median time from study completion to publication. The manuscript development history included the number of times a manuscript was submitted before it was accepted for publication.
Among registered clinical trials for which Pfizer was the sponsor that completed in 2010, 76 met all inclusion criteria. The primary outcome(s) for 65 (85%) studies was published in 71 manuscripts; the median time to publication was 31 months (range 3-63 months). Of the remaining 11 studies, 2 had been submitted to at least one journal, 2 had not yet been submitted and 7 had no plans to publish because the study had terminated early due to recruitment challenges. Manuscripts accepted at the first choice journal were published at median time of 28 months (range 8-63, n=31), those accepted at second choice journal were published at 32 months (3-45, n=19), and for those accepted at third choice journal, it was 40 months (range 24-53, n=13).
The publication rate and median time to publication from study completion for Pfizer-sponsored studies were comparable to those previously reported for combined analyses of industry and non-industry sectors. Opportunities exist for sponsors, authors and journals to explore ideas that would facilitate more timely publication for clinical trial results. However, to be effective, such changes may need to revisit the entire publication process.
评估2010年辉瑞公司资助并在同行评审文献中作为手稿发表的临床试验比例,并评估手稿的发表历程。
回顾性横断面分析。
在ClinicalTrials.gov注册的、2010年完成的、针对辉瑞公司获批的处方产品(用于患者)或健康参与者疫苗的临床试验。
主要结局发表的研究比例以及从研究完成到发表的中位时间。手稿发表历程包括手稿在被接受发表前的提交次数。
在2010年完成的、以辉瑞公司为资助方的注册临床试验中,76项符合所有纳入标准。65项(85%)研究的主要结局发表在71篇手稿中;发表的中位时间为31个月(范围3 - 63个月)。其余11项研究中,2项已提交给至少一家期刊,2项尚未提交,7项因招募困难提前终止研究而无发表计划。在首选期刊被接受的手稿发表中位时间为28个月(范围8 - 63个月,n = 31),在次选期刊被接受的为32个月(3 - 45个月,n = 19),在第三选期刊被接受的为40个月(范围24 - 53个月,n = 13)。
辉瑞公司资助研究的发表率以及从研究完成到发表的中位时间与之前行业和非行业部门联合分析报告的结果相当。资助方、作者和期刊有机会探讨有助于更及时发表临床试验结果的方法。然而,要想有效,此类改变可能需要重新审视整个发表过程。