Malik Sadia Mariam, Ashraf Nabila
1094 Vari Hall, Department of Economics, Faculty of Liberal Arts and Professional Studies, York University, 4700 Keele Street, Toronto, ON, M3J 1P3, Canada.
Department of Economics, Quaid e Azam University, 45320, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Int J Equity Health. 2016 Jul 26;15(1):120. doi: 10.1186/s12939-016-0405-x.
Poor maternal and infant health indicators are mostly concentrated among low income households in Pakistan and health care expenditures - especially on medical emergencies - are the most common income shocks experienced by the poor. Public investments in health are therefore considered as pro-poor interventions by the government of Pakistan. This study employs nationally representative household data for Pakistan for 2007-08 and 2010-11 to investigate whether benefits from publicly financed services on Mother and Newborn Child Health (MNCH) are effectively captured by the poor in terms of service utilization.
The study conducts a Utilization Incidence Analysis of the use of public health services for MNCH in Pakistan. For this purpose, the utilization shares of households, ranked by economic status, are computed. The concentration curves are plotted and their dominance is tested against an equal distribution and Lorenz curves to determine whether the distribution is pro-poor and progressive.
Although the shares of bottom income groups in the utilization of most services for MNCH have increased between 2007 and 2011, the utilization of some services such as post-natal consultation; institutional maternal delivery; and Tetanus Toxoid injections for pregnant women remains pro-rich in 2011. The utilization of pre-natal consultation, especially through lady health workers and visitors; the use of Family Panning Units; and immunization services is somewhat evenly distributed. The use of Basic Health Units (BHUs) is found to be pro-poor. The provincial analysis reveals that the province of Baluchistan depicts an unusually high level of inequity in the distribution of utilization benefits from almost all public health services. Finally, in terms of progressivity, public spending on all health services analyzed in the study is found to be progressive at the national level implying that investment in MNCH has the potential to redistribute income from rich to the poor.
To target the poor effectively, the study recommends expanding the network of BHUs as well as basic reproductive and child health care services. The outreach of health facilities in Baluchistan need to be expanded while targeting the poor effectively by mitigating various access costs that prevent them from using public health services.
巴基斯坦母婴健康指标不佳的情况大多集中在低收入家庭,医疗保健支出——尤其是医疗急救方面的支出——是穷人最常遭遇的收入冲击。因此,巴基斯坦政府将对卫生领域的公共投资视为扶贫干预措施。本研究采用2007 - 2008年和2010 - 2011年巴基斯坦具有全国代表性的家庭数据,以调查穷人在服务利用方面是否有效地获取了公共资助服务对母婴健康(MNCH)的益处。
该研究对巴基斯坦用于母婴健康的公共卫生服务进行了利用发生率分析。为此,计算了按经济状况排名的家庭的利用份额。绘制了集中曲线,并将其优势与均匀分布和洛伦兹曲线进行比较,以确定分布是否有利于穷人且具有累进性。
尽管2007年至2011年期间,最贫困收入群体在大多数母婴健康服务利用中的份额有所增加,但2011年,一些服务的利用情况,如产后咨询、机构内产妇分娩以及为孕妇接种破伤风类毒素疫苗,仍然有利于富人。产前咨询的利用,尤其是通过女性保健工作者和访视员进行的咨询;计划生育单位的使用;以及免疫服务的分布较为均匀。基本卫生单位(BHU)的使用情况有利于穷人。省级分析表明,俾路支省在几乎所有公共卫生服务利用效益的分配方面存在异常高的不平等程度。最后,在累进性方面,研究中分析的所有卫生服务的公共支出在国家层面被发现具有累进性,这意味着对母婴健康的投资有潜力将收入从富人重新分配给穷人。
为了有效地针对穷人,该研究建议扩大基本卫生单位网络以及基本生殖和儿童保健服务。需要扩大俾路支省卫生设施的覆盖范围,同时通过降低阻碍穷人使用公共卫生服务的各种获取成本,有效地针对穷人。