Suppr超能文献

“她们并非真正意义上的原住民,但却很容易交流”:影响澳大利亚原住民女性在孕期披露亲密伴侣暴力行为决定的因素。

'They aren't really black fellas but they are easy to talk to': Factors which influence Australian Aboriginal women's decision to disclose intimate partner violence during pregnancy.

作者信息

Spangaro Jo, Herring Sigrid, Koziol-Mclain Jane, Rutherford Alison, Frail Mary-Anne, Zwi Anthony B

机构信息

School of Social Sciences, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia.

NSW Education Centre Against Violence, Locked Bag 7118, Parramatta BC, NSW 2150, Australia.

出版信息

Midwifery. 2016 Oct;41:79-88. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2016.08.004. Epub 2016 Aug 6.

Abstract

OBJECTIVES

intimate partner violence is a significant global health problem but remains largely hidden. Understanding decisions about whether or not to disclose violence in response to routine enquiry in health settings can inform safe and responsive systems. Elevated rates of violence and systematic disadvantage found among Indigenous women globally, can impact on their decisions to disclose violence. This study aimed to test, among Indigenous women, a model for decisions on whether to disclose intimate partner violence in the context of antenatal routine screening.

DESIGN

we employed Qualitative Configurative Analysis, a method developed for the social sciences to study complex phenomena with intermediate sample sizes. Data were drawn from single semi- structured interviews with Indigenous women 28+ weeks pregnant attending antenatal care. Interviews addressed decisions to disclose recent intimate partner violence in the context of routine enquiry during the antenatal care. Interview transcripts were binary coded for conditions identified a priori from the model being tested and also from themes identified within the current study and analysed using Qualitative Configurative Analysis to determine causal conditions for the outcome of disclosure or non-disclosure of violence experienced.

SETTINGS

five Aboriginal and Maternal Infant Health Services (two urban and three regional), and one mainstream hospital, in New South Wales, Australia.

PARTICIPANTS

indigenous women who had experienced partner violence in the previous year and who had been asked about this as part of an antenatal booking-in visit. Of the 12 participants six had elected to disclose their experience of violence to the midwife, and six had chosen not to do so.

FINDINGS

pathways to disclosure and non-disclosure were mapped using Qualitative Configurative Analysis. Conditions relevant to decisions to disclose were similar to the conditions for non-Aboriginal women found in our earlier study. Unique to Aboriginal women's decisions to disclose abuse was cultural safety. Cultural safety included elements we titled: Borrowed trust, Build the relationship first, Come at it slowly and People like me are here. The absence of cultural safety Its absence was also a factor in decisions not to disclose experiences of violence by this group of women.

KEY CONCLUSIONS

cultural safety was central to Indigenous women's decision to disclose violence and processes for creating safety are identified. Other forms of safety which influenced disclosure included: safety from detection by the abuser; safety from shame; and safety from institutional control. Disclosure was promoted by direct asking by the midwife and a perception of care. Non-disclosure was associated with a lack of care and a lack of all four types of safety. Experiences of institutional racism were associated with Indigenous women's perceived risk of control by others, particularly child protection services.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

policies to ask abuse questions at first visits and models where continuity of care is not maintained, are problematic for Aboriginal women, among whom relationship building is important as is ample warning about questions to be asked. Strategies are needed to build cultural safety to counter widespread racism and promote safe opportunities for Indigenous women to disclose intimate partner violence and receive support. Elements of cultural safety are necessary for vulnerable or marginalised populations to fully utilise available health services.

摘要

目标

亲密伴侣暴力是一个重大的全球健康问题,但在很大程度上仍不为人所知。了解在医疗机构进行常规询问时,关于是否披露暴力行为的决定,可为安全且有响应能力的系统提供信息。全球范围内,原住民女性中暴力发生率较高且存在系统性不利因素,这可能会影响她们披露暴力行为的决定。本研究旨在测试一种模型,用于探究原住民女性在产前常规筛查背景下,决定是否披露亲密伴侣暴力行为的情况。

设计

我们采用了定性构型分析方法,这是一种为社会科学开发的方法,用于研究中等样本量的复杂现象。数据来自对怀孕28周及以上接受产前护理的原住民女性进行的单次半结构化访谈。访谈涉及在产前护理的常规询问中,披露近期亲密伴侣暴力行为的决定。访谈记录针对从所测试模型中预先确定的条件以及本研究中确定的主题进行二元编码,并使用定性构型分析进行分析,以确定经历暴力行为披露或不披露结果的因果条件。

地点

澳大利亚新南威尔士州的五家原住民母婴健康服务机构(两家城市机构和三家地区机构)以及一家主流医院。

参与者

在前一年经历过伴侣暴力行为且在产前预约就诊时被问及此事的原住民女性。12名参与者中,6人选择向助产士披露她们的暴力经历,6人选择不披露。

结果

使用定性构型分析绘制了披露和不披露的路径。与披露决定相关的条件与我们早期研究中发现的非原住民女性的条件相似。原住民女性决定披露虐待行为的独特因素是文化安全。文化安全包括我们命名为:借来的信任、先建立关系、慢慢来以及有像我这样的人在这里等要素。缺乏文化安全也是这组女性决定不披露暴力经历的一个因素。

主要结论

文化安全是原住民女性决定披露暴力行为的核心,并确定了营造安全的过程。影响披露的其他安全形式包括:免受施虐者发现的安全;免受羞耻的安全;以及免受机构控制的安全。助产士的直接询问和关怀感促进了披露。不披露与缺乏关怀以及缺乏所有四种安全类型相关。机构种族主义的经历与原住民女性认为他人,特别是儿童保护服务机构进行控制的风险相关。

对实践的启示

在首次就诊时询问虐待问题的政策以及不保持连续护理的模式,对原住民女性来说存在问题,对她们而言,建立关系很重要,同时对要问的问题给予充分警告也很重要。需要制定策略来建立文化安全,以对抗普遍存在的种族主义,并为原住民女性提供安全的机会来披露亲密伴侣暴力行为并获得支持。文化安全要素对于弱势群体或边缘化群体充分利用现有医疗服务是必要的。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验