Hester Susan D, Bhat Virunya, Chorley Brian N, Carswell Gleta, Jones Wendell, Wehmas Leah C, Wood Charles E
National Health and Environmental Effects Research Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina.
NSF International, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Toxicol Sci. 2016 Dec;154(2):202-213. doi: 10.1093/toxsci/kfw161. Epub 2016 Aug 25.
Use of archival resources has been limited to date by inconsistent methods for genomic profiling of degraded RNA from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) samples. RNA-sequencing offers a promising way to address this problem. Here, we evaluated transcriptomic dose responses using RNA-sequencing in paired FFPE and frozen (FROZ) samples from 2 archival studies in mice, one <2 years old and the other >20 years old. Experimental treatments included 3 different doses of di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate or dichloroacetic acid for the recently archived and older studies, respectively. Total RNA was ribo-depleted and sequenced using the Illumina HiSeq platform. In the recently archived study, FFPE samples had 35% lower total counts compared to FROZ samples but high concordance in fold-change values of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (r =0.99), highly enriched pathways (90% overlap with FROZ), and benchmark dose estimates for preselected target genes (<5% difference vs FROZ). In contrast, older FFPE samples had markedly lower total counts (3% of FROZ) and poor concordance in global DEGs and pathways. However, counts from FFPE and FROZ samples still positively correlated (r = 0.84 across all transcripts) and showed comparable dose responses for more highly expressed target genes. These findings highlight potential applications and issues in using RNA-sequencing data from FFPE samples. Recently archived FFPE samples were highly similar to FROZ samples in sequencing quality metrics, DEG profiles, and dose-response parameters, while further methods development is needed for older lower-quality FFPE samples. This work should help advance the use of archival resources in chemical safety and translational science.
迄今为止,由于对来自福尔马林固定石蜡包埋(FFPE)样本的降解RNA进行基因组分析的方法不一致,档案资源的使用受到限制。RNA测序为解决这一问题提供了一种很有前景的方法。在此,我们在来自两项小鼠档案研究的配对FFPE和冷冻(FROZ)样本中,使用RNA测序评估了转录组剂量反应,其中一项研究样本年龄小于2年,另一项大于20年。实验处理分别包括针对最近存档和较旧研究的3种不同剂量的邻苯二甲酸二(2-乙基己基)酯或二氯乙酸。总RNA经核糖体去除后,使用Illumina HiSeq平台进行测序。在最近存档的研究中,与FROZ样本相比,FFPE样本的总计数低35%,但差异表达基因(DEG)的倍数变化值具有高度一致性(r = 0.99),高度富集的通路(与FROZ有90%的重叠),以及预选靶基因的基准剂量估计(与FROZ相比差异<5%)。相比之下,较旧的FFPE样本的总计数明显更低(为FROZ的3%),并且在全局DEG和通路方面一致性较差。然而,FFPE和FROZ样本的计数仍然呈正相关(所有转录本的r = 0.84),并且对于表达水平更高的靶基因显示出可比的剂量反应。这些发现突出了使用FFPE样本的RNA测序数据的潜在应用和问题。最近存档的FFPE样本在测序质量指标、DEG谱和剂量反应参数方面与FROZ样本高度相似,而对于质量较低的较旧FFPE样本则需要进一步的方法开发。这项工作应有助于推动档案资源在化学安全和转化科学中的应用。