Saito Tetsuo, Toya Ryo, Semba Akiko, Matsuyama Tomohiko, Oya Natsuo
Department of Radiation Oncology, Kumamoto University Hospital, Kumamoto, Japan; Department of Radiation Oncology, Hitoyoshi Medical Center, Hitoyoshi, Japan.
Department of Radiation Oncology, Kumamoto University Hospital, Kumamoto, Japan.
Nagoya J Med Sci. 2016 Aug;78(3):275-84.
We investigated whether the treatment schedule influences physicians' decisions to refer their patients for radiotherapy. We presented a questionnaire to 104 physicians in various specialties at three hospitals. It included three hypothetical patients with uncomplicated painful bone metastasis: patients with an expected life span of one year (case 1), 6 months (case 2), and 2 months (case 3). The physicians were asked whether they would refer their patients for radiotherapy when a radiation oncologist presented three different treatment schedules: a short (8 Gy/1 fraction/1 day)-, a medium (20 Gy/5 fractions/1 week)-, and a long (30 Gy/10 fractions/2 weeks) schedule. We used Cochran's Q-test to compare the percentage of physicians across the three schedules and a mixed-effect logistic model to identify predictors of the selection of only the one-day schedule. Of the 104 physicians, 68 (65%) responded. Of these, 37 (54%), 27 (40%), and 26 (38%) chose to refer patients for radiotherapy when the short-, medium-, and long schedules, respectively, were proposed in case 1 (p = 0.14). These numbers were 44 (65%), 29 (43%), and 15 (22%) for case 2 (p < 0.001), and 59 (87%), 12 (18%), and 1 (1%) for case 3 (p < 0.001). Hypothetical patient and the physicians' years of practice and perspective regarding side effects were independently predictive of the selection of only the one-day schedule. In conclusion, the treatment schedule influenced the physicians' decisions to refer patients for radiotherapy.
我们调查了治疗方案是否会影响医生将患者转诊接受放射治疗的决定。我们向三家医院的104名不同专业的医生发放了一份问卷。问卷包含三名患有非复杂性疼痛性骨转移的虚拟患者:预期寿命为一年的患者(病例1)、6个月的患者(病例2)和2个月的患者(病例3)。当放射肿瘤学家提出三种不同的治疗方案时,即短疗程(8 Gy/1次/1天)、中疗程(20 Gy/5次/1周)和长疗程(30 Gy/10次/2周),医生们被问及是否会将他们的患者转诊接受放射治疗。我们使用 Cochr an Q检验来比较三种方案中医生的百分比,并使用混合效应逻辑模型来确定仅选择一天疗程的预测因素。104名医生中,68名(65%)做出了回应。其中,在病例1中,当分别提出短疗程、中疗程和长疗程方案时,选择将患者转诊接受放射治疗的医生分别为37名(54%)、