Jin Soo Young, Oh Seong Beom, Kim Young Oh
Department of Emergency Medicine, Dankook University College of Medicine, Cheonan, Korea.
Clin Exp Emerg Med. 2016 Mar 31;3(1):27-33. doi: 10.15441/ceem.16.119. eCollection 2016 Mar.
This study aimed to compare the optimal chest compression depth for infants and children with that of adults when the simulated compression depth was delivered according to the current guidelines.
A total of 467 consecutive chest computed tomography scans (93 infants, 110 children, and 264 adults) were reviewed. The anteroposterior diameter and compressible diameter (CD) for infants and children were measured at the inter-nipple level and at the mid-lower half of the spine for adults. Compression ratio (CR) to CD was calculated at simulated 1/4, 1/3, and 1/2 antero-posterior compressions in infants and children, and simulated 5- and 6-cm compressions in adults.
In adults, the CRs to CD at simulated 5- and 6-cm compression depth were 41.7±0.16%, 50.0±7.3% respectively. In children and infants, the CRs to CD at 1/3 chest compression were 55.1±2.4% and 51.8±2.4%, respectively, and at 1/2 chest compression, CRs were 82.7±3.7% and 77.7±3.6%, respectively. The CRs to CD of 4-cm compression depth in infants and 5-cm compression depth in children were 74.4±10.9%, 62.5±8.7%, respectively. The CRs to CD for children and infants were significantly higher than in adults (P<0.001). The CR to CD of 4-cm compression depth in children was almost similar to that of 6-cm compression depth in adults (50.0± 6.9% vs. 50.0±7.3%, P=0.985).
Current pediatric guidelines for compression depth are too deep compared to those in adults. We suggest using 1/3 of the anteroposterior chest diameter or about 4 cm in children and less than 4 cm in infants.
本研究旨在比较当按照现行指南进行模拟按压深度时,婴儿和儿童与成人的最佳胸外按压深度。
回顾了总共467例连续的胸部计算机断层扫描(93例婴儿、110例儿童和264例成人)。在乳头水平测量婴儿和儿童的前后径和可压缩直径(CD),在成人的脊柱中下1/2处测量。计算婴儿和儿童模拟1/4、1/3和1/2前后径按压时以及成人模拟5厘米和6厘米按压时的压缩比(CR)与CD的比值。
在成人中,模拟5厘米和6厘米按压深度时CR与CD的比值分别为41.7±0.16%、50.0±7.3%。在儿童和婴儿中,1/3胸外按压时CR与CD的比值分别为55.1±2.4%和51.8±2.4%,1/2胸外按压时分别为82.7±3.7%和77.7±3.6%。婴儿4厘米按压深度和儿童5厘米按压深度时CR与CD的比值分别为74.4±10.9%、62.5±8.7%。儿童和婴儿的CR与CD的比值显著高于成人(P<0.001)。儿童4厘米按压深度时CR与CD的比值与成人6厘米按压深度时几乎相似(50.0±6.9%对50.0±7.3%,P=0.985)。
与成人相比,目前儿童按压深度指南设定得太深。我们建议儿童使用胸前后径的1/3或约4厘米,婴儿使用小于4厘米。