Institute of Ecology and Earth Sciences, University of Tartu, Lai 40, Tartu, 51005, Estonia.
Institute of Forestry and Rural Engineering, Estonian University of Life Sciences, Kreutzwaldi 5, Tartu, 51014, Estonia.
Glob Chang Biol. 2017 May;23(5):1961-1974. doi: 10.1111/gcb.13540. Epub 2016 Nov 17.
The interactive effects of climate variables and tree-tree competition are still insufficiently understood drivers of forest response to global climate change. Precipitation and air humidity are predicted to rise concurrently at high latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere. We investigated whether the growth response of deciduous trees to elevated air humidity varies with their competitive status. The study was conducted in seed-originated silver birch and monoclonal hybrid aspen stands grown at the free air humidity manipulation (FAHM) experimental site in Estonia, in which manipulated stands (n = 3 for both species) are exposed to artificially elevated relative air humidity (6-7% over the ambient level). The study period included three growing seasons during which the stands had reached the competitive stage (trees were 7 years old in the final year). A significant 'treatment×competitive status' interactive effect on growth was detected in all years in birch (P < 0.01) and in one year in aspen stands (P = 0.015). Competitively advantaged trees were always more strongly affected by elevated humidity. Initially the growth of advantaged and neutral trees of both species remained significantly suppressed in humidified stands. In the following years, dominance and elevated humidity had a synergistic positive effect on the growth of birches. Aspens with different competitive status recovered more uniformly, attaining similar relative growth rates in manipulated and control stands, but preserved a significantly lower total growth yield due to severe initial growth stress. Disadvantaged trees of both species were never significantly affected by elevated humidity. Our results suggest that air humidity affects trees indirectly depending on their social status. Therefore, the response of northern temperate and boreal forests to a more humid climate in future will likely be modified by competitive relationships among trees, which may potentially affect species composition and cause a need to change forestry practices.
气候变量和树木间竞争的相互作用仍然是对森林响应全球气候变化的驱动力了解不足。预计北半球高纬度地区的降水量和空气湿度将同时上升。我们研究了落叶树木对空气湿度升高的生长响应是否随其竞争地位而变化。该研究在爱沙尼亚自由空气湿度操纵(FAHM)实验站的种子起源的银桦和单克隆杂交白杨林分中进行,在该实验站中,操纵林分(每个物种各 3 个林分)暴露于人为升高的相对空气湿度(比环境水平高 6-7%)。研究期间包括三个生长季节,在此期间,林分达到了竞争阶段(最后一年树木为 7 岁)。在所有年份的桦木中(P<0.01)和在一个年份的白杨中(P=0.015),都检测到了显著的“处理×竞争地位”的交互作用。在所有年份的桦木中(P<0.01)和在一个年份的白杨中(P=0.015),都检测到了显著的“处理×竞争地位”的交互作用。在所有年份的桦木中(P<0.01)和在一个年份的白杨中(P=0.015),都检测到了显著的“处理×竞争地位”的交互作用。处于竞争优势的树木总是受到更高湿度的更强烈影响。最初,两种树木的优势和中性树木的生长在加湿林分中仍然受到显著抑制。在随后的几年中,优势地位和高湿度对桦树的生长产生了协同的积极影响。具有不同竞争地位的白杨恢复得更加均匀,在操纵和对照林分中达到相似的相对生长率,但由于初始生长压力较大,总生长产量仍显著较低。两种树木的劣势树木从未受到高湿度的显著影响。我们的结果表明,空气湿度间接影响树木,取决于它们的社会地位。因此,未来更湿润的气候对北温带和北方森林的影响可能会受到树木之间竞争关系的调节,这可能会潜在地影响物种组成,并导致需要改变林业实践。