Salmasi Vafi, Maheshwari Kamal, Yang Dongsheng, Mascha Edward J, Singh Asha, Sessler Daniel I, Kurz Andrea
From the Departments of Outcomes Research and General Anesthesiology (V.S., K.M., D.I.S., A.K.), Departments of Quantitative Health Sciences and Outcomes Research (D.Y., E.J.M.), and Anesthesiology Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio (A.S.).
Anesthesiology. 2017 Jan;126(1):47-65. doi: 10.1097/ALN.0000000000001432.
How best to characterize intraoperative hypotension remains unclear. Thus, the authors assessed the relationship between myocardial and kidney injury and intraoperative absolute (mean arterial pressure [MAP]) and relative (reduction from preoperative pressure) MAP thresholds.
The authors characterized hypotension by the lowest MAP below various absolute and relative thresholds for cumulative 1, 3, 5, or 10 min and also time-weighted average below various absolute or relative MAP thresholds. The authors modeled each relationship using logistic regression. The authors further evaluated whether the relationships between intraoperative hypotension and either myocardial or kidney injury depended on baseline MAP. Finally, the authors compared the strength of associations between absolute and relative thresholds on myocardial and kidney injury using C statistics.
MAP below absolute thresholds of 65 mmHg or relative thresholds of 20% were progressively related to both myocardial and kidney injury. At any given threshold, prolonged exposure was associated with increased odds. There were no clinically important interactions between preoperative blood pressures and the relationship between hypotension and myocardial or kidney injury at intraoperative mean arterial blood pressures less than 65 mmHg. Absolute and relative thresholds had comparable ability to discriminate patients with myocardial or kidney injury from those without.
The associations based on relative thresholds were no stronger than those based on absolute thresholds. Furthermore, there was no clinically important interaction with preoperative pressure. Anesthetic management can thus be based on intraoperative pressures without regard to preoperative pressure.
如何最好地描述术中低血压仍不明确。因此,作者评估了心肌和肾脏损伤与术中绝对(平均动脉压[MAP])和相对(相对于术前压力的降低)MAP阈值之间的关系。
作者通过低于各种绝对和相对阈值累积1、3、5或10分钟时的最低MAP以及低于各种绝对或相对MAP阈值的时间加权平均值来描述低血压。作者使用逻辑回归对每种关系进行建模。作者进一步评估术中低血压与心肌或肾脏损伤之间的关系是否取决于基线MAP。最后,作者使用C统计量比较绝对和相对阈值与心肌和肾脏损伤之间关联的强度。
低于65 mmHg的绝对阈值或20%的相对阈值的MAP与心肌和肾脏损伤均逐渐相关。在任何给定阈值下,暴露时间延长与几率增加相关。在术中平均动脉血压低于65 mmHg时,术前血压与低血压和心肌或肾脏损伤之间的关系不存在临床上重要的相互作用。绝对和相对阈值在区分有心肌或肾脏损伤的患者与无损伤的患者方面具有相当的能力。
基于相对阈值的关联并不比基于绝对阈值的关联更强。此外,与术前压力不存在临床上重要的相互作用。因此,麻醉管理可以基于术中压力,而无需考虑术前压力。