Palomaki Glenn E, Lambert-Messerlian Geralyn M, Haddow James E
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Women & Infants Hospital, Providence, RI.
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2016 Nov;215(5):583-587.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2016.06.046.
Providing reliable prenatal screening performance estimates is critical for patient counseling and policy-making. Women who choose prenatal screening for aneuploidy are likely to be concerned not only with the common aneuploidies but with all causes of intellectual disability and serious birth defects. Sequential prenatal screening (combined serum and ultrasound testing) for aneuploidy detection commonly is offered as a primary screening test. Among women identified as screen positive, cell-free (cf)DNA has been added recently as a secondary, noninvasive screening option, before the consideration of invasive diagnostic testing (eg, amniocentesis and karyotype). With the anticipation of lower costs in the future, cfDNA might be an alternative to sequential screening in the general population. Sequential and cfDNA tests are both noninvasive, and both identify common aneuploidies. Screening via cfDNA detects more common chromosome abnormalities (eg, trisomy 21, sex trisomies). Sequential screening can identify other aneuploidies (eg, triploidy), as well as chromosome abnormalities associated with fetal structural abnormalities. When the advantages and disadvantages of routine sequential screening with routine cfDNA screening are compared, one important measure is the proportion and severity of chromosome abnormalities identified. When reporting these detection rates, authors need to carefully consider the impact of multiple well-described biases. For women to make informed choices in situations of this type, determining reliable comparative performance estimates is crucial.
提供可靠的产前筛查性能评估对于患者咨询和政策制定至关重要。选择进行非整倍体产前筛查的女性可能不仅关注常见的非整倍体情况,还关注智力残疾和严重出生缺陷的所有病因。用于检测非整倍体的序贯产前筛查(联合血清和超声检测)通常作为主要筛查试验提供。在被确定为筛查阳性的女性中,最近在考虑进行侵入性诊断检测(如羊膜穿刺术和核型分析)之前,游离(cf)DNA已作为一种次要的非侵入性筛查选择被加入。鉴于预计未来成本会降低,cfDNA可能成为普通人群序贯筛查的替代方法。序贯筛查和cfDNA检测都是非侵入性的,且都能识别常见的非整倍体。通过cfDNA进行的筛查能检测到更多常见的染色体异常(如21三体、性染色体三体)。序贯筛查可以识别其他非整倍体(如三倍体),以及与胎儿结构异常相关的染色体异常。当比较常规序贯筛查与常规cfDNA筛查的优缺点时,一个重要的衡量标准是所识别的染色体异常的比例和严重程度。在报告这些检测率时,作者需要仔细考虑多种已充分描述的偏倚的影响。为了让女性在这类情况下做出明智的选择,确定可靠的比较性能评估至关重要