J Sport Rehabil. 2017 May;26(3):290-294. doi: 10.1123/jsr.2015-0087. Epub 2016 Nov 11.
Clinical Scenario: Concussions are a prevalent topic in medicine. Concussion symptoms include headaches, dizziness, nausea, neuropsychiatric symptoms, and cognitive impairments, the persistence of which is referred to as postconcussion syndrome. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) has been proposed and evaluated as an additional treatment of these symptoms. HBOT is an innovative approach that has been considered by many but has received both criticism and acceptance.
Is HBOT an effective means of reducing symptoms for individuals suffering from postconcussion syndrome (persistence of symptoms for >3 mo)? Summary of Search: The literature was searched for studies that were relevant to the clinical question. Literature provided 5 level 1 studies that were relevant enough to be considered. Clinical Bottom Line: Based on the research that is available, the authors conclude that there is more evidence to refute the use of HBOT for postconcussion syndrome than to support it. Strength of Recommendation: Four studies disprove the use of HBOT; 1 study supported the use of HBOT. These 5 studies are the same level of evidence (level 1) and provide significant findings in their studies. The strength of this recommendation is a B according to the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine.
临床情况:脑震荡是医学中的一个常见话题。脑震荡的症状包括头痛、头晕、恶心、神经精神症状和认知障碍,这些症状的持续存在被称为脑震荡后综合征。高压氧治疗(HBOT)已被提出并评估为这些症状的附加治疗方法。HBOT 是一种创新的方法,已经被许多人考虑,但也受到了批评和认可。
HBOT 是否是减轻患有脑震荡后综合征(症状持续 >3 个月)个体症状的有效手段?搜索总结:对与临床问题相关的研究进行了文献检索。文献提供了 5 项足够相关以被考虑的 1 级研究。临床底线:根据现有的研究,作者得出结论,有更多证据反对使用 HBOT 治疗脑震荡后综合征,而不是支持它。推荐强度:4 项研究证明 HBOT 无用;1 项研究支持 HBOT 的使用。这 5 项研究具有相同的证据水平(1 级),并在其研究中提供了重要发现。根据循证医学中心的标准,该建议的强度为 B。