Fahed R, Darsaut T E, Salazkin I, Gentric J-C, Mazighi M, Raymond J
From the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (R.F., I.S., J.R.), Interventional Neuroradiology Research Laboratory, Notre-Dame Hospital, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Department of Surgery (T.E.D.), Division of Neurosurgery, University of Alberta Hospital, Mackenzie Health Sciences Centre, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2017 Feb;38(2):317-322. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A5018. Epub 2016 Nov 24.
Rabbit elastase-induced saccular aneurysms have been commonly used for preclinical testing of endovascular devices, including flow diverters. However, all tested devices have been shown to be capable of aneurysm occlusion with this model. We aimed to create a more challenging model to test and discriminate among neurovascular devices of varying efficacies.
With a surgical approach that included elastase infusion and balloon dilation, we attempted the creation of complex fusiform aneurysms in 16 rabbits, with standard saccular carotid aneurysms created in 15 other animals. Aneurysms were randomly allocated to one of the following treatments: flow diversion ( = 8), high-porosity stent ( = 6), double high-porosity stent ( = 5), and control ( = 6). Angiographic assessment and pathologic analyses were performed at 3 months.
Creation of complex fusiform and standard saccular aneurysms was successful in 12/16 and 13/15 attempts, respectively. All saccular ( = 4) or complex fusiform ( = 4) aneurysms treated with flow diverters were successfully occluded. Three of 3 saccular compared with 0/2 complex fusiform aneurysms were occluded by double high-porosity stents. One of 3 saccular and 0/3 complex fusiform aneurysms were occluded by a single high-porosity stent. Both aneurysm types shared the same pathologic findings when untreated: The aneurysm wall lacked an elastic layer and smooth muscle cells, while the lumen was lined with neointima of varying thickness. Neointimal coverage of the devices was complete when aneurysms were occluded, while leaks were always associated with aneurysm remnants.
Challenging fusiform aneurysms can be created in rabbits by using a surgical modification of the elastase method.
兔弹性蛋白酶诱导的囊状动脉瘤常用于包括血流导向装置在内的血管内器械的临床前测试。然而,在此模型中,所有测试器械均显示能够闭塞动脉瘤。我们旨在创建一个更具挑战性的模型,以测试和区分不同疗效的神经血管器械。
采用包括弹性蛋白酶注入和球囊扩张的手术方法,我们试图在16只兔中创建复杂的梭形动脉瘤,在另外15只动物中创建标准的颈囊状动脉瘤。动脉瘤被随机分配至以下治疗组之一:血流导向(n = 8)、高孔隙率支架(n = 6)、双高孔隙率支架(n = 5)和对照组(n = 6)。在3个月时进行血管造影评估和病理分析。
分别在12/16和13/15次尝试中成功创建了复杂梭形和标准囊状动脉瘤。所有接受血流导向治疗的囊状(n = 4)或复杂梭形(n = 4)动脉瘤均成功闭塞。双高孔隙率支架闭塞了3个囊状动脉瘤中的3个,而复杂梭形动脉瘤中闭塞率为0/2。单高孔隙率支架闭塞了3个囊状动脉瘤中的1个,复杂梭形动脉瘤中闭塞率为0/3。两种类型的动脉瘤在未治疗时具有相同的病理表现:动脉瘤壁缺乏弹性层和平滑肌细胞,而管腔内衬有厚度不一的新生内膜。当动脉瘤闭塞时,器械的新生内膜覆盖完整,而渗漏总是与动脉瘤残余相关。
通过对弹性蛋白酶方法进行手术改良,可在兔中创建具有挑战性的梭形动脉瘤。