Knerlich-Lukoschus Friederike, Connolly Mary B, Hendson Glenda, Steinbok Paul, Dunham Christopher
Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Schleswig-Holstein Campus Kiel, Germany; and.
Divisions of 2 Pediatric Neurosurgery and.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2017 Feb;19(2):182-195. doi: 10.3171/2016.8.PEDS1686. Epub 2016 Nov 25.
OBJECTIVE Focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) Type II is divided into 2 subgroups based on the absence (IIA) or presence (IIB) of balloon cells. In particular, extratemporal FCD Type IIA and IIB is not completely understood in terms of clinical, imaging, biological, and neuropathological differences. The aim of the authors was to analyze distinctions between these 2 formal entities and address clinical, MRI, and immunohistochemical features of extratemporal epilepsies in children. METHODS Cases formerly classified as Palmini FCD Type II nontemporal epilepsies were identified through the prospectively maintained epilepsy database at the British Columbia Children's Hospital in Vancouver, Canada. Clinical data, including age of seizure onset, age at surgery, seizure type(s) and frequency, affected brain region(s), intraoperative electrocorticographic findings, and outcome defined by Engel's classification were obtained for each patient. Preoperative and postoperative MRI results were reevaluated. H & E-stained tissue sections were reevaluated by using the 2011 International League Against Epilepsy classification system and additional immunostaining for standard cellular markers (neuronal nuclei, neurofilament, glial fibrillary acidic protein, CD68). Two additional established markers of pathology in epilepsy resection, namely, CD34 and α-B crystallin, were applied. RESULTS Seven nontemporal FCD Type IIA and 7 Type B cases were included. Patients with FCD Type IIA presented with an earlier age of epilepsy onset and slightly better Engel outcome. Radiology distinguished FCD Types IIA and IIB, in that Type IIB presented more frequently with characteristic cortical alterations. Nonphosphorylated neurofilament protein staining confirmed dysplastic cells in dyslaminated areas. The white-gray matter junction was focally blurred in patients with FCD Type IIB. α-B crystallin highlighted glial cells in the white matter and subpial layer with either of the 2 FCD Type II subtypes and balloon cells in patients with FCD Type IIB. α-B crystallin positivity proved to be a valuable tool for confirming the histological diagnosis of FCD Type IIB in specimens with rare balloon cells or difficult section orientation. Distinct nonendothelial cellular CD34 staining was found exclusively in tissue from patients with MRI-positive FCD Type IIB. CONCLUSIONS Extratemporal FCD Types IIA and IIB in the pediatric age group exhibited imaging and immunohistochemical characteristics; cellular immunoreactivity to CD34 emerged as an especially potential surrogate marker for lesional FCD Type IIB, providing additional evidence that FCD Types IIA and IIB might differ in their etiology and biology. Although the sample number in this study was small, the results further support the theory that postoperative outcome-defined by Engel's classification-is multifactorial and determined by not only histology but also the extent of the initial lesion, its location in eloquent areas, intraoperative electrocorticographic findings, and achieved resection grade.
目的 Ⅱ型局灶性皮质发育不良(FCD)根据是否存在气球样细胞分为2个亚组(ⅡA和ⅡB)。特别是,颞叶外ⅡA型和ⅡB型FCD在临床、影像学、生物学和神经病理学差异方面尚未完全明确。作者旨在分析这2种形式实体之间的差异,并探讨儿童颞叶外癫痫的临床、MRI和免疫组化特征。方法 通过加拿大温哥华不列颠哥伦比亚儿童医院前瞻性维护的癫痫数据库,识别以前分类为PalminiⅡ型非颞叶癫痫的病例。获取每位患者的临床数据,包括癫痫发作起始年龄、手术年龄、发作类型及频率、受累脑区、术中皮质脑电图结果以及Engel分级定义的结局。对术前和术后MRI结果进行重新评估。使用2011年国际抗癫痫联盟分类系统对苏木精-伊红(H&E)染色的组织切片进行重新评估,并对标准细胞标志物(神经元核、神经丝、胶质纤维酸性蛋白、CD68)进行额外免疫染色。应用另外两种癫痫切除术中既定的病理学标志物,即CD34和α-B晶状体蛋白。结果 纳入7例ⅡA型和7例ⅡB型非颞叶FCD病例。ⅡA型FCD患者癫痫发作起始年龄较早,Engel结局略好。影像学可区分ⅡA型和ⅡB型FCD,ⅡB型更常出现特征性皮质改变。非磷酸化神经丝蛋白染色证实了发育异常区域的发育异常细胞。ⅡB型FCD患者白质与灰质交界处局部模糊。α-B晶状体蛋白在2种Ⅱ型FCD亚型的白质和软膜下层突出显示胶质细胞,在ⅡB型FCD患者中突出显示气球样细胞。α-B晶状体蛋白阳性被证明是在气球样细胞罕见或切片方向困难的标本中确认ⅡB型FCD组织学诊断的有价值工具。仅在MRI阳性的ⅡB型FCD患者组织中发现独特的非内皮细胞CD34染色。结论 儿童年龄组的颞叶外ⅡA型和ⅡB型FCD表现出影像学和免疫组化特征;细胞对CD34的免疫反应性成为ⅡB型病变性FCD特别潜在的替代标志物,提供了额外证据表明ⅡA型和ⅡB型FCD在病因和生物学方面可能存在差异。尽管本研究样本量较小,但结果进一步支持以下理论,即Engel分级定义的术后结局是多因素的,不仅由组织学决定,还由初始病变的范围、其在功能区的位置、术中皮质脑电图结果以及实现的切除分级决定。