Desai S J, Barr R D, Andrew M, deVeber L L, Pai M K
Department of Pediatrics, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.
CMAJ. 1989 Oct 1;141(7):693-7.
There is ample evidence of the value of intensive therapeutic strategies in the management of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), the commonest form of malignant disease in children. Such a program, devised at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (DFCI), Boston, and incorporating high-dose L-asparaginase, was adopted in 1984 by the Children's Hospital at Chedoke-McMaster, Hamilton, Ont., and the Children's Hospital of Western Ontario, London. We describe the experience of these institutions in the treatment of 82 children with ALL, 19 of whom were switched to the DFCI protocols while in continuing first remission with other treatment programs to complete a minimum of 2 years of maintenance therapy; the remaining 63 children, who had recently diagnosed disease, were consecutively enrolled in the DFCI protocols. Each child was assigned at diagnosis to a category of risk for relapse and treated accordingly. There were no remission induction failures or deaths due to induction therapy among the patients with newly diagnosed disease. There were no differences in total or event-free survival rates between the patients in Hamilton and those in London or between those whose protocols were switched and those who were treated from the beginning with the DFCI protocols. With a median follow-up interval of 144 weeks the total survival rate was 95% and the event-free survival rate 88%. For patients at standard risk of relapse the event-free survival rate was 100%, for those at high risk the rate was 82%, and for those at very high risk the rate was 67%. If infants (all of whom suffered a relapse) are excluded from the last category the rate was 89%. These results were achieved with moderate toxic effects (except for two deaths, one of which was due to a therapeutic misadventure) and suggest that the prospect for cure in children with ALL. may now approximate 80%, a degree of success that demands that consideration be given to reducing total therapy, at least for children with standard-risk disease. Further follow-up will determine whether these high event-free survival rates will stabilize and meet the criteria for cure.
有充分证据表明强化治疗策略在急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL,儿童最常见的恶性疾病形式)的管理中具有价值。由波士顿的达纳-法伯癌症研究所(DFCI)设计并纳入高剂量L-天冬酰胺酶的这样一个方案,于1984年被安大略省汉密尔顿的切多克-麦克马斯特儿童医院以及伦敦的西安大略儿童医院采用。我们描述了这些机构治疗82例ALL患儿的经验,其中19例在接受其他治疗方案持续首次缓解期间转用DFCI方案以完成至少2年的维持治疗;其余63例近期诊断疾病的患儿连续纳入DFCI方案。每个患儿在诊断时被分配到一个复发风险类别并据此进行治疗。新诊断疾病的患者中没有因诱导治疗导致的缓解诱导失败或死亡。汉密尔顿的患者与伦敦的患者之间,以及方案转用者与从一开始就接受DFCI方案治疗者之间,总生存率或无事件生存率均无差异。中位随访间隔为144周时,总生存率为95%,无事件生存率为88%。对于标准复发风险的患者,无事件生存率为100%,高风险患者为82%,极高风险患者为67%。如果将婴儿(他们全部复发)从最后一组排除,该比例为89%。这些结果是在中度毒性作用下取得的(除了两例死亡,其中一例是由于治疗失误),表明ALL患儿的治愈前景现在可能接近80%,这一成功程度要求考虑至少对标准风险疾病的患儿减少总治疗量。进一步随访将确定这些高无事件生存率是否会稳定并达到治愈标准。