Fountoulakis K N, Balaris D, Nikolaou V, Νimatoudis J
3rd Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine.
Psychiatrist, Thessaloniki, Greece.
Psychiatriki. 2016 Oct-Dec;27(4):253-263. doi: 10.22365/jpsych.2016.274.253.
Bipolar disorder (BD) has a complex and variable clinical picture which is characterized by many different phacets and phases and as a result its therapeutical options are also complex and often unsatisfactory. Typically the so-called "mood stabilizers" are used in the treatment of BD and in this class lithium and specific antiepileptics are included. The present study aimed to systematically review the literature concerning the presence of randomized double blind clinical trials of 'non conventional' pharmaceutical treatment options. The present systematic review utilized the PRISMA method and searched the MEDLINE through January 1st 2015 with the use of appropriate key words. In order to identify randomized controlled trials- RCTs a combination of the words "bipolar", "manic", "mania", "manic depression" and "manic depressive" with "randomized" was used. Webpages with lists of trials were also searched including http://clinicaltrials.gov and http://www.clinicalstudyresults.org as well as the official webpages of all pharma companies with products marketed in the treatment of BD. The reference lists of various review papers were also searched. The MEDLINE was searched with the combination of the words "guidelines" or "algorithms" with "mania", "manic", "bipolar", "manicdepressive" or "manic depression" in order to identify articles with treatment guidelines. The reference list of these articles were also scanned. From 3,284 papers which were initially traced, only 47 papers were included in the present study. From those agents studied in acute mania, tamoxifen is efficacious as monotherapy and as combination therapy with lithium and other mood stabilizers, however its safety profile is relatively poor. Allopurinol manifests efficacy in combination with lithium but not with other agents and its safety profile is satisfactory. Methoxyprogesterone is efficacious in combination with mood stabilizers and its safety profile is very good. In acute bipolar depression the combinations of FEWP with carbamazepine and ketamine, modafinil, pramipexole, pregnenolone and maybe armodafinil with mood stabilizers are efficacious. The safety profile of these combinations is medium. The use of celecoxib, lisdexamfetamine and memantine have negative data. Concerning the maintenance treatment, the data are negative for memantine and for Nacetylcysteine. Although most of the data concerning the usefulness of "non-conventional" pharmacotherapeutic agents in the treatment of bipolar disorder are negative, it is encouraging that those agents who have been proven efficacious probably exert their therapeutic effect through pathways which differ from usual and probably different from those classically considered in most biological models of bipolar illness. In this way there constitute new paradigms and open new horizons in the understanding of the disease.
双相情感障碍(BD)具有复杂多变的临床症状,其特征表现为诸多不同方面和阶段,因此其治疗选择也很复杂且往往不尽人意。通常,所谓的“心境稳定剂”用于治疗BD,此类药物包括锂盐和特定的抗癫痫药。本研究旨在系统回顾有关“非传统”药物治疗方案随机双盲临床试验存在情况的文献。本系统评价采用PRISMA方法,并于2015年1月1日前使用适当关键词检索了MEDLINE。为了识别随机对照试验(RCT),使用了“双相”“躁狂”“躁狂症”“躁郁症”和“躁狂抑郁”与“随机”的组合词。还搜索了包含试验列表的网页,包括http://clinicaltrials.gov和http://www.clinicalstudyresults.org,以及所有销售用于治疗BD产品的制药公司的官方网页。还搜索了各种综述论文的参考文献列表。为了识别有治疗指南的文章,在MEDLINE中使用了“指南”或“算法”与“躁狂症”“躁狂”“双相”“躁郁症”或“躁郁症”的组合词进行搜索。这些文章的参考文献列表也进行了扫描。从最初检索到的3284篇论文中,本研究仅纳入了47篇论文。在急性躁狂症研究的药物中,他莫昔芬作为单一疗法以及与锂盐和其他心境稳定剂联合使用时有效,但其安全性相对较差。别嘌醇与锂盐联合使用时显示出疗效,但与其他药物联合使用时无效,其安全性令人满意。甲氧基孕酮与心境稳定剂联合使用有效,其安全性非常好。在急性双相抑郁中,FEWP与卡马西平和氯胺酮、莫达非尼、普拉克索、孕烯醇酮以及可能的阿戈美拉汀与心境稳定剂联合使用有效。这些联合用药的安全性中等。塞来昔布、赖氨酸右旋安非他命和美金刚的使用数据为阴性。关于维持治疗,美金刚和N-乙酰半胱氨酸的数据为阴性。尽管关于“非传统”药物治疗双相情感障碍有效性的大多数数据为阴性,但令人鼓舞的是,那些已被证明有效的药物可能通过与通常不同且可能不同于双相情感障碍大多数生物学模型中经典考虑的途径发挥其治疗作用。通过这种方式,在疾病的理解方面构成了新的范式并开辟了新的视野。