Boesen Lars
Dan Med J. 2017 Feb;64(2).
Prostate cancer (PCa) is the second leading cause of cancer-related mortality and the most frequently diagnosed male malignant disease among men in the Nordic countries. The manifestation of PCa ranges from indolent to highly aggressive disease and due to this high variation in PCa progression, the diagnosis and subsequent treatment planning can be challenging. The current diagnostic approach with PSA testing and digital rectal examination followed by transrectal ultrasound biopsies (TRUS-bx) lack in both sensitivity and specificity in PCa detection and offers limited information about the aggressiveness and stage of the cancer. Scientific work supports the rapidly growing use of multiparametric magnetic resonance imaging (mp-MRI) as the most sensitive and specific imaging tool for detection, lesion characterisation and staging of PCa. However, the experience with mp-MRI in PCa management in Denmark has been very limited. Therefore, we carried out this PhD project based on three original studies to evaluate the use of mp-MRI in detection, assessment of biological aggression and staging of PCa in a Danish setup with limited experience in mp-MRI prostate diagnostics. The aim was to assess whether mp-MRI could 1) improve the overall detection rate of clinically significant PCa previously missed by TRUS-bx, 2) identify patients with extracapsular tumour extension and 3) categorize the histopathological aggressiveness based on diffusion-weighted imaging.
Study I included patients with a history of negative TRUS-bx and persistent suspicion of PCa scheduled for repeated biopsies. Mp-MRI was performed prior to the biopsies and analysed for suspicious lesions. All lesions were scored according to the PIRADS classification from the European Society of Urogenital Radiology's (ESUR) MR prostate guidelines. The lesions were given a sum of scores (ranging 3-15) and classified overall on a Likert five-point scale according to the probability of clinically significant malignancy being present. All patients underwent systematic TRUS-bx (ten cores) and visual mp-MRI-targeted biopsies (mp-MRI-bx) under TRUS-guidance of any mp-MRI-suspicious lesion not hit on systematic TRUS-bx. Study II included patients with clinically localised PCa (cT1-T2) determined by digital rectal examination and/or TRUS and scheduled for radical prostatectomy (RP). Mp-MRI was performed prior to RP, and all lesions were evaluated according to the PIRADS classification and the extracapsular extension (ECE) risk scoring from the ESUR MR prostate guidelines. The images were evaluated by two readers with different experience in mp-MRI interpretation. An mp-MRI T-stage (cTMRI) and an ECE risk score were assigned. Additionally, suspicion of ECE was dichotomised into either organ-confined disease or ECE based on tumour characteristics and personal opinion incorporating functional imaging findings. The RP histopathological results served as standard reference. Study III included patients from study II, where mean ADCtumour values from all malignant tumour foci ≥ 5 mm identified on histopathology were measured on the corresponding diffusion-weighted imaging ADCmap. An ADCbenign value was obtained from a non-cancerous area using the histopathological map as a reference to calculate the ADCratio (ADCtumour divided by ADCbenign). The ADC measurements (ADCtumour and ADCratio values) were correlated with the Gleason score (GS) from each tumour foci.
Eighty-three patients were included in study I. PCa was found in 39/83 (47%) and both the PIRADS summation score and the over-all Likert classification showed a high correlation with biopsy results (p < 0.0001). Five patients (13%) had PCa detected only on mp-MRI-bx outside the systematic biopsy areas (p = 0.025) and another 7 patients (21%) had an overall GS upgrade of at least one grade (p = 0.037) based on the mp-MRI-bx. Clinical significant PCa was found in 37/39 patients according to the Epstein criteria (2004). Eighty-seven patients were included in study II and underwent mp-MRI before RP. The correlation between cTMRI and pT showed a spearman rho correlation of 0.658 (p < 0.001) and 0.306 (p = 0.004) with a weighted kappa of 0.585 [CI 0.44;0.73] and 0.22 [CI 0.09;0.35] for reader A and reader B, respectively. The prevalence of ECE after RP was 31/87 (36%). ECE risk scoring showed an AUC of 0.65-0.86 on the ROC-curve for readers and a sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy of 81% (CI 63;93),78% (CI 66;88) and 79% at the best cut-off level (risk score ≥ 4) for the most experienced reader. When tumour characteristics were influenced by personal opinion and functional imaging, the sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy for prediction of ECE changed to 74% (CI 55;88), 88% (CI 76;95) and 83% for reader A and 61% (CI 0.42;0.78), 77% (CI 0.64;0.87) and 71% for reader B, respectively. Seventy-one patients were included in study III. The association between ADC measurements and GS showed a significantly negative correlation (p < 0.001) with spearman rho for ADCtumour (-0.421) and ADCratio (-0.649), respectively. There was a statistical significant difference between both ADC measurements and the GS groups for all tumours (p < 0.001). ROC-curve analysis showed an overall AUC of 0.73 (ADCtumour) to 0.80 (ADCratio) in discriminating GS 6 from GS ≥ 7 (3+4) tumours. The AUC remained virtually unchanged at 0.72 (ADCtumour), but increased to 0.90 (ADCratio) when discriminating GS ≤ 7 (3+4) from GS ≥ 7 (4+3).
Mp-MRI prior to repeated biopsies can improve the detection rate of clinically significant PCa and allow for a more accurate GS by combining standard TRUS-bx with mp-MRI-targeted biopsies under visual TRUS-guidance. Mp-MRI can provide valuable information about the histopathological aggressiveness of a PCa lesion and the tumour stage with possible ECE can be assessed in the pre-therapeutic setting providing important additional information for optimal patient-tailored treatment planning.
前列腺癌(PCa)是北欧国家癌症相关死亡的第二大原因,也是男性中最常被诊断出的恶性疾病。PCa的表现从惰性疾病到高度侵袭性疾病不等,由于PCa进展存在高度差异,其诊断和后续治疗规划可能具有挑战性。目前采用前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)检测和直肠指检,随后进行经直肠超声活检(TRUS-bx)的诊断方法在PCa检测中缺乏敏感性和特异性,并且提供的有关癌症侵袭性和分期的信息有限。科学研究支持多参数磁共振成像(mp-MRI)作为检测、病变特征描述和PCa分期的最敏感和特异的成像工具的使用迅速增加。然而,丹麦在PCa管理中使用mp-MRI的经验非常有限。因此,我们基于三项原创研究开展了这个博士项目,以评估在丹麦mp-MRI前列腺诊断经验有限的情况下,mp-MRI在PCa检测、生物学侵袭性评估和分期中的应用。目的是评估mp-MRI是否能够:1)提高先前TRUS-bx漏诊的临床显著性PCa的总体检测率;2)识别有包膜外肿瘤扩展的患者;3)基于扩散加权成像对组织病理学侵袭性进行分类。
研究I纳入有TRUS-bx阴性病史且持续怀疑PCa并计划进行重复活检的患者。在活检前进行mp-MRI,并分析可疑病变。所有病变均根据欧洲泌尿生殖放射学会(ESUR)的MR前列腺指南中的前列腺影像报告和数据系统(PIRADS)分类进行评分。病变被赋予一个总分(范围为3 - 15分),并根据存在临床显著性恶性肿瘤的概率总体按照李克特五点量表进行分类。所有患者均接受系统的TRUS-bx(十个穿刺点)以及在TRUS引导下对系统TRUS-bx未命中的任何mp-MRI可疑病变进行可视mp-MRI靶向活检(mp-MRI-bx)。研究II纳入经直肠指检和/或TRUS确定为临床局限性PCa(cT1 - T2)且计划进行根治性前列腺切除术(RP)的患者。在RP前进行mp-MRI,所有病变均根据ESUR的MR前列腺指南中的PIRADS分类和包膜外扩展(ECE)风险评分进行评估。由两位在mp-MRI解读方面经验不同的阅片者对图像进行评估。指定一个mp-MRI T分期(cTMRI)和一个ECE风险评分。此外,根据肿瘤特征并结合功能成像结果,将对ECE的怀疑分为器官局限性疾病或ECE。RP的组织病理学结果作为标准参考。研究III纳入研究II中的患者,在对应的扩散加权成像ADC图上测量组织病理学确定的所有直径≥5 mm的恶性肿瘤灶的平均肿瘤表观扩散系数(ADCtumour)值。使用组织病理学图作为参考,从非癌区域获得一个ADC良性值,以计算ADC比率(ADCtumour除以ADC良性)。将ADC测量值(ADCtumour和ADC比率值)与每个肿瘤灶的Gleason评分(GS)进行相关性分析。
研究I纳入83例患者。在39/83(47%)的患者中发现了PCa,PIRADS总分和总体李克特分类均与活检结果显示出高度相关性(p < 0.0001)。5例患者(13%)仅在系统活检区域外的mp-MRI-bx中检测到PCa(p = 0.025),另外7例患者(21%)基于mp-MRI-bx总体GS至少提升了一个等级(p = 0.037)。根据爱泼斯坦标准(2004年),在37/39例患者中发现了临床显著性PCa。研究II纳入87例患者,并在RP前进行了mp-MRI。cTMRI与pT之间的相关性显示,阅片者A的斯皮尔曼等级相关系数为0.658(p < 0.001),加权kappa为0.585 [CI 0.44;0.73],阅片者B的斯皮尔曼等级相关系数为0.306(p = 0.004),加权kappa为0.22 [CI 0.09;0.35]。RP后ECE的患病率为31/87(36%)。ECE风险评分在阅片者的ROC曲线上的AUC为0.65 - 0.86,对于经验最丰富的阅片者,在最佳截断水平(风险评分≥4)时,敏感性、特异性和诊断准确性分别为81%(CI 63;93)、78%(CI 66;88)和79%。当肿瘤特征受个人意见和功能成像影响时,阅片者A预测ECE的敏感性、特异性和诊断准确性分别变为74%(CI 55;88)、88%(CI 76;95)和83%,阅片者B分别变为61%(CI 0.42;0.78)、77%(CI 0.64;0.87)和71%。研究III纳入71例患者。ADC测量值与GS之间的关联显示出显著的负相关性(p < 0.001),ADCtumour的斯皮尔曼等级相关系数为 - 0.421,ADC比率的斯皮尔曼等级相关系数为 - 0.649。对于所有肿瘤,ADC测量值与GS组之间均存在统计学显著差异(p < 0.001)。ROC曲线分析显示,在区分GS 6与GS≥7(3 + 4)肿瘤时,ADCtumour的总体AUC为0.73,ADC比率的总体AUC为0.80。在区分GS≤7(3 + 4)与GS≥7(4 + 3)肿瘤时,ADCtumour的AUC基本保持不变,为0.72,但ADC比率的AUC增加到0.90。
在重复活检前进行mp-MRI,通过在可视TRUS引导下将标准TRUS-bx与mp-MRI靶向活检相结合,可以提高临床显著性PCa的检测率,并实现更准确的GS。mp-MRI可以提供有关PCa病变组织病理学侵袭性的有价值信息,并且可以在治疗前评估可能存在ECE的肿瘤分期,为优化个体化患者治疗规划提供重要的额外信息。