Higgins B G, Britton J R, Chinn S, Jones T D, Jenkinson D, Burney P G, Tattersfield A E
Respiratory Medicine Unit, City Hospital, Nottingham, UK.
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1989 Nov;140(5):1368-72. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm/140.5.1368.
Although serial peak expiratory flow (PEF) measurements are often used to assess the variability of airflow obstruction, the range of values to be expected in the general population has never been defined, nor is there any consensus as to how PEF variability should be expressed. We have compared PEF recordings made by 121 subjects selected at random from the population of a small town (Group A) and 221 subjects selected because of wheeze in the last year (Group B). Subjects were asked to record PEF every 2 h during waking hours for 7 days using a mini-Wright peak flow meter. Seven indices of PEF variability were derived for each subject and the range for each index determined. All indices showed a positively skewed distribution in the random sample. Two variability indices, standard deviation percent mean and amplitude percent mean, provided the greatest separation between subjects with both a diagnosis of asthma and wheeze in the last year and subjects with neither feature and also provided the highest intra-class correlation coefficients. We conclude that amplitude percent mean and standard deviation percent mean provide the best means of expressing PEF variability for epidemiological purposes, but that amplitude percent mean is more easily derived and appears to be the index of choice. PEF variability has a continuous distribution in the general population and no clear-cut division between asthmatic and nonasthmatic subjects can be defined.
尽管连续呼气峰值流速(PEF)测量常用于评估气流阻塞的变异性,但普通人群中预期的PEF值范围从未明确界定,对于如何表示PEF变异性也没有达成共识。我们比较了从一个小镇的人群中随机选取的121名受试者(A组)和因去年有喘息症状而入选的221名受试者(B组)的PEF记录。要求受试者在清醒时间每2小时使用小型赖特峰值流量计记录一次PEF,持续7天。为每个受试者得出7个PEF变异性指标,并确定每个指标的范围。在随机样本中,所有指标均呈正偏态分布。两个变异性指标,即标准差占均值百分比和振幅占均值百分比,在去年既有哮喘诊断又有喘息症状的受试者与既无这些特征的受试者之间提供了最大的区分度,并且类内相关系数也最高。我们得出结论,对于流行病学目的而言,振幅占均值百分比和标准差占均值百分比是表示PEF变异性的最佳方法,但振幅占均值百分比更容易得出,似乎是首选指标。在普通人群中,PEF变异性呈连续分布,无法明确界定哮喘患者和非哮喘患者之间的界限。