Shi Yanjie, Chen Ying, Li Xiaoting, Wang Zhilong, Sun Yingshi
Key Laboratory of Carcinognenesis and Translational Research of Ministry of Education,Department of Radiology,Peking University Cancer Hospital & Institute,Beijing 100142,China.
Zhongguo Yi Xue Ke Xue Yuan Xue Bao. 2017 Feb 20;39(1):133-139. doi: 10.3881/j.issn.1000-503X.2017.01.022.
Objective To assess the diagnostic accuracy of multidetector CT (MDCT) for restaging of patients with esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) after neoadjuvant chemotherapy and determine the feasibility of CT for assessing the treatment response and evaluating the prognosis. Methods Totally 135 patients with esophageal SCC who had received neoadjuvant treatment and surgery in Beijing Cancer Hospital from September 2005 to December 2011 were enrolled in this study. TN staging was performed using CT for lesions before and after neoadjuvant treatment by two radiologists,and the tumor regression grade (TRG) and pathological TRG were also assessed. Based on preoperative CT TN restaging results,the patients were defined as responders with TN after therapy,non-responders with T3-4N+,and patients with undefined response (TN0 or TNN). Results The accuracy of T and N restaging using CT was 50%,54% (κ=0.718,P <0.001) and 59%,56% (κ=0.753,P <0.001) by two radiologists,respectively. TRG from CT was predicted correctly in 27% of patients. Pathological TRG was an accurate predictor of survival (χ =8.13,P=0.04). There was no significant trend toward better survival for lower CT TRG (χ =1.17,P=0.286). Among 135 patients with esophageal cancer,19 patients(14.07%) were responders ,46 patients(34.07%) were non-responders,and 70 patients (50.37%)were patients with undefined response . The overall survival rates of responders,non-responders and patients with undefined response were 71.5%,47.3%,and 18.5%,respectively. The overall survival of responders was better than that of patients with undefined response (χ=1.518,P=0.63) and non-responders(χ=12.04,P=0.0016),but the overall survival of patients with undefined response was better than that of non-responders (χ=14.468,P=0.0003). Conclusion sMDCT restaging after neoadjuvant treatment can not accurately predict pathological stage in esophageal SCC. The CT T and N restaging has certain clinical value in assessing the response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy in patients with esophageal cancer and predicting the prognosis.
目的 评估多排螺旋CT(MDCT)对食管鳞状细胞癌(SCC)患者新辅助化疗后再分期的诊断准确性,并确定CT评估治疗反应和判断预后的可行性。方法 选取2005年9月至2011年12月在北京肿瘤医院接受新辅助治疗及手术的135例食管SCC患者。由两名放射科医生对新辅助治疗前后的病变进行CT检查以进行TN分期,同时评估肿瘤退缩分级(TRG)和病理TRG。根据术前CT TN再分期结果,将患者分为治疗后TN反应者、T3 - 4N +无反应者以及反应不明确患者(TN0或TNN)。结果 两名放射科医生利用CT进行T和N再分期的准确率分别为50%、54%(κ = 0.718,P < 0.001)和59%、56%(κ = 0.753,P < 0.001)。27%的患者CT预测TRG正确。病理TRG是生存的准确预测指标(χ = 8.13,P = 0.04)。CT TRG较低者无明显更好的生存趋势(χ = 1.17,P = 0.286)。135例食管癌患者中,19例(14.07%)为反应者,46例(34.07%)为无反应者,70例(50.37%)为反应不明确患者。反应者、无反应者和反应不明确患者的总生存率分别为71.5%、47.3%和18.5%。反应者的总生存优于反应不明确患者(χ = 1.518,P = 0.63)和无反应者(χ = 12.04,P = 0.0016),但反应不明确患者的总生存优于无反应者(χ = 14.468,P = 0.0003)。结论 新辅助治疗后MDCT再分期不能准确预测食管SCC的病理分期。CT T和N再分期在评估食管癌患者新辅助化疗反应及预测预后方面具有一定临床价值。