Bannister Peter
Department of Botany, University of Otago, P.O. Box 56, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Oecologia. 1989 Apr;79(1):128-132. doi: 10.1007/BF00378249.
The nitrogen concentration in photosynthetic organs of 41 pairs of mistletoes and their respective hosts was compared and found to be higher (in relation to that of their hosts) in cryptic mistletoes and lower in non-cryptic mistletoes. This supports the hypothesis that crypsis may have evolved as a mechanism for avoiding predation by vertebrate herbivores. There were no consistent differences between the nitrogen concentrations of hosts and mistletoes in trees and larger-leaved shrubs (whether native or introduced). The largest differences between mistletoes and their hosts were found on small-leaved divaricate shrubs (Coprosma ssp., Melicope simplex) where the nitrogen concentrations in cryptic mistletoes (Korthalsella spp.) were significantly higher than in their hosts, but significantly lower in prominent mistletoes (Loranthus micranthus, Tupeia antarctica) which apparently "advertise" their unpalatability. If crypsis in New Zealand mistletoes evolved as a protection against herbivory, then it must have evolved in the absence of mammalian herbivores, and the appropriate selection pressures could have been provided only by moas, extinct ratite birds. Otherwise, alternative explanations, such as differing relationships between water use and nitrogen uptake, must be sought for the observed associations of nitrogen concentration and cryptic mimicry in New Zealand mistletoes.
对41对槲寄生及其各自寄主的光合器官中的氮浓度进行了比较,发现隐匿性槲寄生的氮浓度(相对于其寄主而言)较高,而非隐匿性槲寄生的氮浓度较低。这支持了这样一种假说,即拟态可能是作为一种避免被脊椎动物食草动物捕食的机制而进化出来的。在树木和大叶灌木(无论本地的还是引进的)中,寄主和槲寄生的氮浓度之间没有一致的差异。在小叶二叉状灌木(如新西兰苦槛蓝属植物、单叶蜜茱萸)上,槲寄生与其寄主之间的差异最大,在这些植物上,隐匿性槲寄生(如矮槲寄生属植物)的氮浓度显著高于其寄主,但在明显“表明”其不可口的显眼槲寄生(小花桑寄生、南极图佩亚桑寄生)中,氮浓度则显著较低。如果新西兰槲寄生的拟态是作为一种防止食草作用的保护机制而进化出来的,那么它一定是在没有哺乳动物食草动物的情况下进化的,而适当的选择压力可能只由恐鸟(已灭绝的平胸鸟类)提供。否则,就必须为新西兰槲寄生中观察到的氮浓度与隐匿拟态之间的关联寻找其他解释,比如水分利用和氮吸收之间的不同关系。