Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Jena University Hospital, Friedrich-Schiller-University of Jena, Philosophenweg 3, 07743 Jena, Germany.
Department of Differential Psychology and Psychological Assessment, Institute of Psychology, Goethe University of Frankfurt am Main, Theodor-W.-Adorno-Platz 6, 60323 Frankfurt, Germany.
Psychiatry Res. 2017 Jul;253:9-12. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2017.01.093. Epub 2017 Feb 3.
Group schema therapy (GST) has been proposed as a novel long-term treatment programme for borderline and cluster C personality disorders. We implemented a short-term GST programme (12-15 sessions, based on the manual by Farrell and Shaw (2012), including both cognitive / behavioural and experiential interventions for in-patients (n=9) with either borderline or cluster C personality disorders (and axis I co-morbidities) treated in a (sub)acute psychiatric in-patient setting. We evaluated pre- and post-treatment self-report of maladaptive and adaptive schema modes (using the SMI) and early maladaptive schemas (YSQ-3), as well as overall symptom severity (brief symptom check list, BSCL-53-S), patient satisfaction (ZUF-8) and group climate and coherence (GCQ-S). We found significant reduction of symptoms, and trend-level improvement for schema mode activation, but not maladaptive schemas. Effect sizes of Cohen's d=0.857 for symptoms and d=0.693 for maladaptive schema mode reduction were, however, lower than previous GST trials in in-patient settings with a longer treatment phase and outpatient GST trials using the Farrell and Shaw-model, indicating importance of duration in ST treatment. Our findings in this uncontrolled study provide first evidence that GST (based on the Farrell and Shaw model) can be implemented and adapted for use in short-term in-patient (sub)acute settings.
小组图式治疗(GST)已被提议作为一种新的长期治疗方案,用于治疗边缘型和 C 群人格障碍。我们实施了一个短期 GST 方案(12-15 次会议,基于 Farrell 和 Shaw(2012 年)的手册,包括认知/行为和体验干预,用于在急性精神病住院环境中接受治疗的(伴有或不伴有轴 I 共病的)边缘型或 C 群人格障碍患者(n=9)。我们评估了治疗前后的自我报告的适应不良和适应模式(使用 SMI)和早期适应不良模式(YSQ-3),以及总体症状严重程度(简短症状检查表,BSCL-53-S),患者满意度(ZUF-8)和团体氛围和一致性(GCQ-S)。我们发现症状显著减轻,模式激活的趋势水平改善,但适应不良模式没有改善。Cohen 的 d 值为 0.857 的症状和 d 值为 0.693 的适应不良模式减少的效果大小低于以前在住院环境中进行的具有更长治疗阶段的 GST 试验和使用 Farrell 和 Shaw 模型的门诊 GST 试验,表明 ST 治疗的持续时间很重要。我们在这项非对照研究中的发现首次提供了证据,表明 GST(基于 Farrell 和 Shaw 模型)可以在短期住院(亚急性)环境中实施和适应。