O'Carroll Ronan E, Haddow Lorna, Foley Laura, Quigley Jody
Division of Psychology, Faculty of Natural Sciences, University of Stirling, UK.
Br J Health Psychol. 2017 Sep;22(3):577-588. doi: 10.1111/bjhp.12248. Epub 2017 May 26.
There are approximately 6,500 people on the UK national transplant waiting list, around 400 of whom die every year. Only 35% of the UK population are currently on the organ donation register. We report two studies examining whether a reciprocity prime, in which participants were asked whether they would accept a donated organ, increased organ donation intentions and behaviour.
Between-participants, randomized controlled design.
In two studies, participants who were not currently registered organ donors took part either face-to-face or online and were randomly allocated to a reciprocity prime or control condition. Following the manipulation, they were asked to indicate, on either a paper or online questionnaire, their intention to join the organ donor register. Study 2 was similar to Study 1 but with the addition that after reporting intention, participants were then offered an organ donation information leaflet or the opportunity to click a link for further information (proxy behavioural measure).
In both studies, reciprocity primed participants reported greater intentions to register than controls. However, in Study 2, no effect on donation behaviour was found.
Reciprocal altruism may be a useful tool in increasing intentions to join the organ donor register. Further evaluation is required to determine whether this increase in intention can be translated into organ donation behaviour. Statement of contribution What was already known? Demand for organs in the United Kingdom far outstrips supply, so finding strategies to increase registration on the organ donor register could save hundreds of lives per year. Despite the majority of people in the United Kingdom agreeing that organ donation is a good thing, most people do not register as donors. A limited amount of evidence of the impact of perceived reciprocity suggests that encouraging people to consider themselves as recipients and priming ideas of shared responsibility may increase the likelihood of their subsequent willingness to register. What does this study add? Novel evidence that employing a simple reciprocity prime increases organ donor registration intentions. Replication of findings across two separate studies. Novel examination of the impact of mode of delivery of messages to encourage organ donation. A basis for further research into the translation of intentions into organ donor registration behaviour.
英国国家器官移植等待名单上约有6500人,其中每年约有400人死亡。目前,只有35%的英国人口在器官捐赠登记册上。我们报告了两项研究,探究一种互惠启动方式(即询问参与者是否会接受捐赠器官)是否会增加器官捐赠意愿和行为。
组间随机对照设计。
在两项研究中,未登记为器官捐赠者的参与者通过面对面或在线方式参与研究,并被随机分配到互惠启动组或对照组。在进行干预后,要求他们在纸质问卷或在线问卷上表明加入器官捐赠登记册的意愿。研究2与研究1相似,但增加了一点,即在报告意愿后,为参与者提供一份器官捐赠信息传单,或让他们有机会点击链接获取更多信息(代理行为测量)。
在两项研究中,接受互惠启动的参与者报告的登记意愿均高于对照组。然而,在研究2中,未发现对捐赠行为有影响。
互惠利他主义可能是增加加入器官捐赠登记册意愿的有用工具。需要进一步评估,以确定这种意愿的增加是否能转化为器官捐赠行为。贡献声明已知的情况是什么?英国对器官的需求远远超过供应,因此找到增加器官捐赠登记册登记人数的策略每年可以挽救数百人的生命。尽管英国大多数人都认为器官捐赠是件好事,但大多数人并未登记成为捐赠者。关于感知互惠影响的有限证据表明,鼓励人们将自己视为接受者并启动共同责任的观念,可能会增加他们随后登记的可能性。这项研究增加了什么?采用简单的互惠启动方式可增加器官捐赠登记意愿的新证据。在两项独立研究中重复研究结果。对鼓励器官捐赠的信息传递方式的影响进行新的研究。将意愿转化为器官捐赠登记行为的进一步研究的基础。