Seymour Brittany, Shick Elizabeth, Chaffee Benjamin W, Benzian Habib
Dr. Seymour is Assistant Professor, Department of Oral Health Policy and Epidemiology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine; Dr. Shick is Assistant Professor, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dental Medicine, University of Colorado; Dr. Chaffee is Assistant Professor, Department of Preventive and Restorative Dental Sciences, School of Dentistry, University of California, San Francisco; and Dr. Benzian is Adjunct Professor of Epidemiology and Health Promotion, College of Dentistry, New York University.
J Dent Educ. 2017 Jun;81(6):707-715. doi: 10.21815/JDE.016.034.
The Global Oral Health Interest Group of the Consortium of Universities for Global Health (GOHIG-CUGH) published recommended competencies to support development of competency-based global health education in dental schools. However, there has been no comprehensive, systematically derived, or broadly accepted framework for creating and delivering competency-based global health education to dental students. This article describes the results of a collaborative workshop held at the 2016 American Dental Education Association (ADEA) Annual Session & Exhibition designed to build on the GOHIG-CUGH competencies and start to develop systematic approaches for their practical application. Workshop organizers developed a preliminary theoretical framework for guiding the development of global health in dental education, grounded in published research. Collectively, workshop participants developed detailed outcomes for the theoretical framework with a focus on three educational practices: didactic, experiential, and research learning and how each can meet the competencies. Participants discussed learning objectives, keys to implementation, ethical considerations, challenges, and examples of success. Outcomes demonstrated that no educational practice on its own meets all 33 recommended competencies for dental students; however, the three educational practices combined may potentially cover all 33. Participants emphasized the significance of sustainable approaches to student learning for both students and communities, with identified partners in the communities to collaborate on the development, implementation, evaluation, and long-term maintenance of any student global health activity. These findings may represent early steps toward professional consensus and best practices for global health in dental education in the United States.
全球健康大学联盟全球口腔健康兴趣小组(GOHIG-CUGH)发布了推荐的能力标准,以支持牙科学院开展基于能力的全球健康教育。然而,目前还没有一个全面的、系统推导出来的或被广泛接受的框架,用于为牙科学生创建和提供基于能力的全球健康教育。本文介绍了在2016年美国牙科教育协会(ADEA)年会暨展览会上举办的一次合作研讨会的成果,该研讨会旨在以GOHIG-CUGH的能力标准为基础,并开始为其实际应用开发系统方法。研讨会组织者基于已发表的研究,制定了一个初步的理论框架,以指导牙科教育中全球健康的发展。研讨会参与者共同为该理论框架制定了详细的成果,重点关注三种教育实践:讲授式、体验式和研究性学习,以及每种实践如何满足这些能力标准。参与者讨论了学习目标、实施要点、伦理考量、挑战和成功案例。结果表明,没有一种教育实践能单独满足为牙科学生推荐的所有33项能力标准;然而,这三种教育实践结合起来可能涵盖所有33项标准。参与者强调了对学生和社区而言可持续的学生学习方法的重要性,确定了社区中的合作伙伴,以便就任何学生全球健康活动的开发、实施、评估和长期维护进行合作。这些发现可能代表着在美国牙科教育中朝着全球健康的专业共识和最佳实践迈出的早期步伐。