Walczak Brian E, Blankenbaker Donna G, Tuite Michael R, Keene James S
Department of Orthopedics and Rehabilitation, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
Orthop J Sports Med. 2017 May 25;5(5):2325967117707498. doi: 10.1177/2325967117707498. eCollection 2017 May.
Iliopsoas (IP) muscle atrophy is a known consequence of open IP tenotomy, but the severity of IP muscle atrophy that occurs after arthroscopic labral-level IP tenotomies has not been documented.
To document the severity of muscle atrophy that occurs in the iliacus, psoas, and adjacent hip musculature after arthroscopic labral-level IP tenotomy.
Case series; Level of evidence, 4.
Twenty-eight patients who had magnetic resonance arthrograms (MRAs) obtained prior to and 3 months to 5 years after arthroscopic labral-level IP tenotomies are the basis of this report. The pre- and postoperative MRAs of each patient were examined in consensus by 2 musculoskeletal radiologists who graded the postoperative muscle atrophy from 0 (no fatty infiltration) to 4 (>75% fatty infiltration) and noted any compensatory muscle hypertrophy or abnormal IP tendon morphology. Patients also were assessed with the Byrd 100-point modified Harris Hip Scoring system (MHHS) preoperatively and at the time of their postoperative MRA.
Postoperative MRAs were obtained on average 1.7 years (range, 3 months to 5 years) after hip arthroscopy. None of the patients had muscle atrophy on their preoperative MRAs. In contrast, 89% of patients had iliacus and psoas muscle atrophy on their postoperative MRAs, but only 2 (7%) developed grade 4 atrophy, and the majority (64%) had either grade 1 (n = 15) or no atrophy (n = 3). In addition, there were no significant differences in the MHHS of the patients with mild (grades 0-1), moderate (grades 2-3), or severe (grade 4) postoperative atrophy. Postoperative MRAs also demonstrated low-grade atrophy (grades 1-2) in the quadratus femoris (n = 5) and rectus femoris (n = 1) muscles, and 16 patients (57%) had distortion of the tendon, but none had a gap in their tendon.
A majority of patients (89%) developed IP muscle atrophy after arthroscopic labral-level IP tenotomies, and although this percentage was similar (89% vs 90%) to that reported with lesser trochanteric IP tenotomies, the patients did not (1) develop atrophy of the gluteus maximus and vastus lateralis muscles, (2) have chronic IP tendon disruption, or (3) develop the severity of IP atrophy (55% grade 4 vs 7% grade 4) that has been reported after arthroscopic lesser trochanteric IP tenotomies.
髂腰肌(IP)肌肉萎缩是开放性IP肌腱切断术的已知后果,但关节镜下盂唇水平IP肌腱切断术后发生的IP肌肉萎缩的严重程度尚无文献记载。
记录关节镜下盂唇水平IP肌腱切断术后髂肌、腰大肌及相邻髋部肌肉发生的肌肉萎缩的严重程度。
病例系列;证据等级,4级。
本报告基于28例患者,这些患者在关节镜下盂唇水平IP肌腱切断术前及术后3个月至5年进行了磁共振关节造影(MRA)检查。2名肌肉骨骼放射科医生共同检查了每位患者的术前和术后MRA,将术后肌肉萎缩程度从0级(无脂肪浸润)分级至4级(脂肪浸润>75%),并记录任何代偿性肌肉肥大或异常的IP肌腱形态。患者还在术前及术后MRA检查时采用伯德100分改良Harris髋关节评分系统(MHHS)进行评估。
髋关节镜检查后平均1.7年(范围3个月至5年)获得术后MRA。所有患者术前MRA均未出现肌肉萎缩。相比之下,89%的患者术后MRA出现髂肌和腰大肌萎缩,但只有2例(7%)发展为4级萎缩,大多数(64%)为1级(n = 15)或无萎缩(n = 3)。此外,轻度(0-1级)、中度(2-3级)或重度(4级)术后萎缩患者的MHHS无显著差异。术后MRA还显示股方肌(n = 5)和股直肌(n = 1)出现低度萎缩(1-2级),16例患者(57%)肌腱形态异常,但无一例肌腱出现间隙。
大多数患者(89%)在关节镜下盂唇水平IP肌腱切断术后出现IP肌肉萎缩,尽管这一比例与小转子水平IP肌腱切断术报告的比例相似(89%对90%),但这些患者未(1)出现臀大肌和股外侧肌萎缩,(2)发生慢性IP肌腱断裂,或(3)出现关节镜下小转子水平IP肌腱切断术后报告的IP萎缩严重程度(55%为4级对7%为4级)。