Laboratory of Thermodynamics in Emerging Technologies, Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering, ETH Zurich , Sonneggstrasse 3, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Langmuir. 2017 Jul 11;33(27):6708-6718. doi: 10.1021/acs.langmuir.7b01412. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
Ice accumulation hinders the performance of, and poses safety threats for, infrastructure both on the ground and in the air. Previously, rationally designed superhydrophobic surfaces have demonstrated some potential as a passive means to mitigate ice accretion; however, further studies on material solutions that reduce impalement and the contact time for impacting supercooled droplets (high viscosity) and can also repel droplets that freeze during surface contact are urgently needed. Here we demonstrate the collaborative effect of substrate flexibility and surface micro/nanotexture on enhancing both icephobicity and the repellency of viscous droplets (typical of supercooled water). We first investigate the influence of increased viscosity (spanning from 0.9 to 1078 mPa·s using water-glycerol mixtures) on impalement resistance and the droplet-substrate contact time after impact. Then we examine the effect of droplet partial solidification on recoil and simulate more challenging icing conditions by impacting supercooled water droplets (down to -15 °C) onto flexible and rigid surfaces containing ice nucleation promoters (AgI). We demonstrate a passive mechanism for shedding partially solidified (recalescent) droplets-under conditions where partial solidification occurs much faster than the natural droplet oscillation-which does not rely on converting droplet surface energy into kinetic energy (classic recoil mechanism). Using an energy-based model (kinetic-elastic-capillary), we identify a previously unexplored mechanism whereby the substrate oscillation and velocity govern the rebound process, with low areal density and moderately stiff substrates acting to efficiently absorb the incoming droplet kinetic energy and rectify it back, allowing droplets to overcome adhesion and gravitational forces, and recoil. This mechanism applies for a range of droplet viscosities, spanning from low- to high-viscosity fluids and even ice slurries, which do not rebound from rigid superhydrophobic substrates. For a low-viscosity fluid, i.e., water, if the substrate oscillates faster than the droplet spreading and retraction, the action of the substrate is decoupled from the droplet oscillation, resulting in a reduction in the droplet-substrate contact time.
冰的积聚会妨碍地面和空中基础设施的性能,并对其安全构成威胁。以前,经过合理设计的超疏水表面已经显示出作为一种减轻积冰的被动手段具有一定的潜力;然而,仍然迫切需要进一步研究能够减少刺穿和撞击过冷液滴(高粘度)的接触时间的材料解决方案,同时还能够排斥在表面接触过程中冻结的液滴。在这里,我们展示了基底柔韧性和表面微纳结构在提高疏冰性和排斥粘性液滴(典型的过冷水)能力方面的协同作用。我们首先研究了粘度增加(使用水-甘油混合物从 0.9 到 1078 mPa·s)对刺穿阻力和撞击后液滴-基底接触时间的影响。然后,我们研究了液滴部分凝固对回弹的影响,并通过将过冷水滴(低至-15°C)撞击到含有成冰促进剂(AgI)的柔性和刚性表面上,模拟更具挑战性的结冰条件。我们展示了一种部分凝固(复辉)液滴的被动脱落机制-在部分凝固发生得比自然液滴振荡快得多的情况下-这种机制不依赖于将液滴表面能转化为动能(经典的回弹机制)。使用基于能量的模型(动能-弹性-毛细),我们确定了一种以前未被探索的机制,其中基底振荡和速度控制回弹过程,具有低密度和适度刚性的基底能够有效地吸收传入液滴的动能并将其校正回来,使液滴能够克服附着力和重力,实现回弹。这种机制适用于从低粘度到高粘度流体甚至冰浆的一系列液滴粘度,从刚性超疏水基底反弹的液滴不会回弹。对于低粘度流体,即水,如果基底的振荡速度快于液滴的扩展和收缩速度,那么基底的作用就会与液滴的振荡分离,从而减少液滴-基底的接触时间。