Nathena Despoina, Michopoulou Effrosyni, Kranioti Elena F
Department of Forensic Sciences, University of Crete, Medical School, Heraklion, Greece.
Edinburgh Unit for Forensic Anthropology, School of History, Classics and Archaeology, University of Edinburgh, 4 Teviot place, EH8 9AG Edinburgh, UK.
Forensic Sci Int. 2017 Aug;277:260.e1-260.e8. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2017.04.005. Epub 2017 Apr 15.
During the past decade, several studies have been carried out using the calcaneus bone for sex estimation. This paper collected data using ten variables for metric characteristics of the calcaneus of 144 modern Cretans and examined their correlation with known sex. Secondly, the formulae developed by Peckmann et al. (2015) for modern Athenians was put to the test in order to investigate if it could be applied to this modern Cretan sample as well. Results showed a high correlation between the calcaneus metrics and the known sex of the individuals, however the formulae for Athenians do not seem to be suitable for the Cretans due to the high sex bias reported in this study. Thus, new standards were created for sex estimation from the calacanei in our sample. Bilateral asymmetry was noted in the majority of cases, thus formulae were developed for left, right and mean values. Maximum width (MAXW) was the variable that performed the best in the Cretan sample. Overall, the cross-validated accuracies for univariate and multivariate equations reached 84.2% with males most often correctly identified. The calcaneus was proved to be useful for sex estimation in this modern Cretan population. Further work will explore the suitability of the produced standards for other regions of mainland Greece and islands.
在过去十年中,已经开展了多项利用跟骨进行性别估计的研究。本文收集了144名现代克里特人的跟骨度量特征的十个变量的数据,并研究了它们与已知性别的相关性。其次,对Peckmann等人(2015年)为现代雅典人开发的公式进行了测试,以调查其是否也适用于这个现代克里特人样本。结果表明,跟骨度量与个体已知性别之间存在高度相关性,然而,由于本研究中报告的高性别偏差,雅典人的公式似乎不适用于克里特人。因此,我们为样本中根据跟骨进行性别估计创建了新的标准。在大多数情况下都发现了双侧不对称性,因此针对左侧、右侧和平均值开发了公式。最大宽度(MAXW)是在克里特人样本中表现最佳的变量。总体而言,单变量和多变量方程的交叉验证准确率达到84.2%,男性最常被正确识别。在这个现代克里特人群体中,跟骨被证明可用于性别估计。进一步的工作将探索所产生的标准对希腊大陆其他地区和岛屿的适用性。