Kumar Arunaz, Nestel Debra, East Christine, Hay Margaret, Lichtwark Irene, McLelland Gayle, Bentley Deidre, Hall Helen, Fernando Shavi, Hobson Sebastian, Larmour Luke, Dekoninck Philip, Wallace Euan M
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Monash University, Clayton, Australia.
School of Rural Health, HealthPEER, Monash University, Clayton, Australia.
Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 2018 Feb;58(1):40-46. doi: 10.1111/ajo.12659. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
Simulation-based programs are increasingly being used to teach obstetrics and gynaecology examinations, but it is difficult to establish student learning acquired through them. Assessment may test student learning but its role in learning itself is rarely recognised. We undertook this study to assess medical and midwifery student learning through a simulation program using a pre-test and post-test design and also to evaluate use of assessment as a method of learning.
The interprofessional simulation education program consisted of a brief pre-reading document, a lecture, a video demonstration and a hands-on workshop. Over a 24-month period, 405 medical and 104 midwifery students participated in the study and were assessed before and after the program. Numerical data were analysed using paired t-test and one-way analysis of variance. Students' perceptions of the role of assessment in learning were qualitatively analysed.
The post-test scores were significantly higher than the pre-test (P < 0.001) with improvements in scores in both medical and midwifery groups. Students described the benefit of assessment on learning in preparation of the assessment, reinforcement of learning occurring during assessment and reflection on performance cementing previous learning as a post-assessment effect.
Both medical and midwifery students demonstrated a significant improvement in their test scores and for most students the examination process itself was a positive learning experience.
基于模拟的课程越来越多地用于教授妇产科检查,但很难确定学生通过这些课程获得的学习成果。评估可以测试学生的学习情况,但其在学习本身中的作用却很少得到认可。我们开展这项研究,通过一个采用预测试和后测试设计的模拟课程来评估医学和助产专业学生的学习情况,并评估将评估作为一种学习方法的效果。
跨专业模拟教育课程包括一份简短的预读文档、一次讲座、一次视频演示和一次实践工作坊。在24个月的时间里,405名医学专业学生和104名助产专业学生参与了该研究,并在课程前后接受了评估。对数值数据采用配对t检验和单因素方差分析进行分析。对学生对评估在学习中作用的看法进行了定性分析。
后测试成绩显著高于预测试成绩(P < 0.001),医学和助产专业组的成绩均有所提高。学生们描述了评估对学习的益处,包括为评估做准备、在评估过程中强化学习以及在评估后反思表现以巩固之前的学习。
医学和助产专业学生的测试成绩均有显著提高,对大多数学生来说,考试过程本身就是一次积极的学习经历。