Vu Alexander F, Chundury Rao V, Perry Julian D
*Cleveland Clinic, Cole Eye Institute, Cleveland, OH †Eugene and Marilyn Glick Eye Institute, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN.
J Craniofac Surg. 2017 Jul;28(5):e460-e463. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000003741.
To compare the results of a mechanical 3-dimensional laser scanner for craniofacial measurements of the basicranium to a validated coordinate device.
Access was granted by the Cleveland Natural History Museum to evaluate the Hamann-Todd Human Osteological Collection for this study. The MicroScribe and the FaroArm were used to gather coordinate data of various bony landmarks measurements including the prosthion, staphylion, hormion, and basion. Seventy-three human skulls were measured and scanned. Distances calculated from the coordinates were tested for agreement using the Bland-Altman test.
There were no significant differences in the bias or slope measures between the MicroScribe and the FaroArm. In addition to the univariate test for slope significance, multivariable analysis using age, gender, and race as additional predictors showed no significant difference in any variable (P < 0.05).
This is the first study demonstrating agreement of the FaroArm in any human skull measurement with the validated MicroScribe digitizer. Compared with the MicroScribe digitizer, the FaroArm allows for 3-dimensional imaging and the ability to store, handle, and view data digitally. Future use of real-time facial measurements using the FaroArm offers potential for improved surgical planning and outcomes.
将一种用于颅底颅面测量的机械三维激光扫描仪的结果与一种经过验证的坐标设备进行比较。
克利夫兰自然历史博物馆批准使用哈曼 - 托德人类骨骼收藏进行本研究评估。使用MicroScribe和FaroArm收集包括前鼻棘、后鼻孔点、鼻额缝中点和颅底点等各种骨性标志测量的坐标数据。对73个人类头骨进行了测量和扫描。使用布兰德 - 奥特曼检验对从坐标计算出的距离进行一致性检验。
MicroScribe和FaroArm之间在偏差或斜率测量方面没有显著差异。除了对斜率显著性的单变量检验外,将年龄、性别和种族作为额外预测因素的多变量分析显示,任何变量均无显著差异(P < 0.05)。
这是第一项证明FaroArm在任何人类头骨测量中与经过验证的MicroScribe数字化仪具有一致性的研究。与MicroScribe数字化仪相比,FaroArm允许进行三维成像,并具有数字存储、处理和查看数据的能力。未来使用FaroArm进行实时面部测量可为改善手术规划和结果提供潜力。