Nagmoti Jyoti Mahantesh
Professor of Microbiology, J N Medical College and Former Director, University Department of Education for Health Professions, KLE University, Belgaum, Karnataka, India.
Indian J Med Microbiol. 2017 Apr-Jun;35(2):199-203. doi: 10.4103/ijmm.IJMM_16_251.
PowerPoint (PPT™) presentation has become an integral part of day-to-day teaching in medicine. Most often, PPT™ is used in its default mode which in fact, is known to cause boredom and ineffective learning. Research has shown improved short-term memory by applying multimedia principles for designing and delivering lectures. However, such evidence in medical education is scarce. Therefore, we attempted to evaluate the effect of multimedia principles on enhanced learning of parasitology.
Second-year medical students received a series of lectures, half of the lectures used traditionally designed PPT™ and the rest used slides designed by Mayer's multimedia principles. Students answered pre and post-tests at the end of each lecture (test-I) and an essay test after six months (test-II) which assessed their short and long term knowledge retention respectively. Students' feedback on quality and content of lectures were collected.
Statistically significant difference was found between post test scores of traditional and modified lectures (P = 0.019) indicating, improved short-term memory after modified lectures. Similarly, students scored better in test II on the contents learnt through modified lectures indicating, enhanced comprehension and improved long-term memory (P < 0.001). Many students appreciated learning through multimedia designed PPT™ and suggested for their continued use.
It is time to depart from default PPT™ and adopt multimedia principles to enhance comprehension and improve short and long term knowledge retention. Further, medical educators may be trained and encouraged to apply multimedia principles for designing and delivering effective lectures.
PowerPoint(PPT™)演示文稿已成为医学日常教学中不可或缺的一部分。大多数情况下,PPT™以默认模式使用,而实际上,这种模式会导致枯燥和学习效果不佳。研究表明,应用多媒体原则设计和授课可提高短期记忆力。然而,医学教育领域的此类证据很少。因此,我们试图评估多媒体原则对寄生虫学强化学习的效果。
二年级医学生接受了一系列讲座,其中一半讲座使用传统设计的PPT™,其余讲座使用根据梅耶尔多媒体原则设计的幻灯片。学生在每次讲座结束时回答课前和课后测试(测试一),并在六个月后进行一次论文测试(测试二),分别评估他们的短期和长期知识保留情况。收集了学生对讲座质量和内容的反馈。
传统讲座和改进讲座的课后测试成绩之间存在统计学上的显著差异(P = 0.019),表明改进后的讲座短期记忆力有所提高。同样,学生在测试二中通过改进讲座所学内容的得分更高,表明理解能力增强且长期记忆力提高(P < 0.001)。许多学生赞赏通过多媒体设计的PPT™进行学习,并建议继续使用。
是时候摒弃默认的PPT™,采用多媒体原则来增强理解能力,提高短期和长期知识保留率了。此外,医学教育工作者可能需要接受培训并受到鼓励,应用多媒体原则设计和讲授有效的讲座。