Trout Andrew T, Wallihan Daniel B, Serai Suraj, Abu-El-Haija Maisam
Department of Radiology, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH.
Levine Children's Hospital, Charlotte, NC.
J Pediatr. 2017 Sep;188:186-191. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.06.031. Epub 2017 Jul 8.
To assess the accuracy and interrater reproducibility of measurements of pancreatic secretory function by magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography in response to secretin administration and to describe our experience using the technique to noninvasively assess pancreatic secretory function in a pediatric population.
In the accuracy study, phantoms with varying fluid volume (47-206 mL) were imaged using the clinical quantification sequence. Fluid volume was measured by image segmentation (ImageJ). Measurement accuracy was expressed in terms of error (absolute and percent) relative to known fluid volume. In the reproducibility study and clinical experience, 31 patients with suspected pancreatic disease underwent 33 secretin-enhanced magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography exams. Two-dimensional T2-weighted, fat-saturated single shot fast spin echo sequences were acquired before and after secretin injection (0.2 µg/kg, max 16 µg). Secreted fluid volume (postsecretin minus presecretin) was independently measured by 2 blinded reviewers. Between reviewer measurement reproducibility was assessed based on correlation (Spearman) and bias (Bland-Altman analysis).
For the accuracy study, fluid volumes were measured with mean volume errors of -0.3 to +12.5 mL (percent error -0.03% to +9.0%). For the reproducibility study, the mean secreted fluid volumes measured by reviewer 1 and reviewer 2 were 79.1 ± 54.3 mL (range 5.5-215.4) and 77.2 ± 47.1 mL (range 6.7-198.1 mL), respectively. Measured secreted fluid volumes were very strongly correlated (r = 0.922) between reviewers with a bias of only 1.9 mL (95% limits of agreement -40.5 to 44.2).
Measurement of fluid volume by magnetic resonance imaging is highly accurate with <10% (<13 mL) error in measured volume. Measurements of pancreatic secreted fluid volume in response to secretin by magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography are highly reproducible with a bias of <2 mL between reviewers.
评估磁共振胰胆管造影术在注射促胰液素后测量胰腺分泌功能的准确性和观察者间的可重复性,并描述我们使用该技术对儿科人群进行胰腺分泌功能无创评估的经验。
在准确性研究中,使用临床定量序列对具有不同液体体积(47 - 206 mL)的体模进行成像。通过图像分割(ImageJ)测量液体体积。测量准确性以相对于已知液体体积的误差(绝对误差和百分比误差)表示。在可重复性研究和临床经验方面,31例疑似胰腺疾病的患者接受了33次促胰液素增强磁共振胰胆管造影检查。在注射促胰液素(0.2 μg/kg,最大16 μg)前后采集二维T2加权、脂肪饱和单次激发快速自旋回波序列。由2名盲法审阅者独立测量分泌的液体体积(注射促胰液素后减去注射前)。基于相关性(Spearman)和偏差(Bland - Altman分析)评估审阅者之间测量的可重复性。
在准确性研究中,测量的液体体积平均体积误差为 - 0.3至 + 12.5 mL(百分比误差为 - 0.03%至 + 9.0%)。在可重复性研究中,审阅者1和审阅者2测量的平均分泌液体体积分别为79.1 ± 54.3 mL(范围5.5 - 215.4)和77.2 ± 47.1 mL(范围6.7 - 198.1 mL)。审阅者之间测量的分泌液体体积高度相关(r = 0.922),偏差仅为1.9 mL(95%一致性界限为 - 40.5至44.2)。
通过磁共振成像测量液体体积高度准确,测量体积误差<10%(<13 mL)。通过磁共振胰胆管造影术测量促胰液素刺激后胰腺分泌的液体体积具有高度可重复性,审阅者之间的偏差<2 mL。