Van Ness Peter H, Murphy Terrence E, Ali Ather
Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA.
J Mix Methods Res. 2017 Jul;11(3):342-354. doi: 10.1177/1558689815623685. Epub 2016 Jan 11.
In several ways, randomized controlled trials represent a high standard of rigor in clinical biomedical research. Randomized controlled trials fail, however, to yield knowledge applicable to specific individuals. This article presents a methodological rationale for a mixed methods approach to n-of-1 clinical studies that attends to the preferences and concerns of individuals while attaining high standards of qualitative and quantitative rigor. An illustrative research design involving a hypothetical music therapy intervention for a quality of life outcome is examined in some detail and a concluding argument is made that the proposed mixed methods approach is especially appropriate for early-stage research interventions intended to generate explanatory hypotheses.
在多个方面,随机对照试验代表了临床生物医学研究的高标准严谨性。然而,随机对照试验未能产生适用于特定个体的知识。本文提出了一种混合方法用于单病例(n-of-1)临床研究的方法学依据,该方法在关注个体偏好和关切的同时,达到定性和定量严谨性的高标准。详细考察了一个涉及假设性音乐疗法干预以改善生活质量结果的说明性研究设计,并得出结论:所提出的混合方法特别适用于旨在生成解释性假设的早期研究干预。