Solomon Nancy Pearl, Makashay Matthew J, Helou Leah B, Clark Heather M
National Military Audiology & Speech Pathology Center, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, MD.
Systems Neuroscience Institute, University of Pittsburgh, PA.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2017 Aug 15;26(3):951-960. doi: 10.1044/2017_AJSLP-16-0144.
This study compared orofacial strength between adults with dysarthria and neurologically normal (NN) matched controls. In addition, orofacial muscle weakness was examined for potential relationships to speech impairments in adults with dysarthria.
Matched groups of 55 adults with dysarthria and 55 NN adults generated maximum pressure (Pmax) against an air-filled bulb during lingual elevation, protrusion and lateralization, and buccodental and labial compressions. These orofacial strength measures were compared with speech intelligibility, perceptual ratings of speech, articulation rate, and fast syllable-repetition rate.
The dysarthria group demonstrated significantly lower orofacial strength than the NN group on all tasks. Lingual strength correlated moderately and buccal strength correlated weakly with most ratings of speech deficits. Speech intelligibility was not sensitive to dysarthria severity. Individuals with severely reduced anterior lingual elevation Pmax (< 18 kPa) had normal to profoundly impaired sentence intelligibility (99%-6%) and moderately to severely impaired speech (26%-94% articulatory imprecision; 33%-94% overall severity).
Results support the presence of orofacial muscle weakness in adults with dysarthrias of varying etiologies but reinforce tenuous links between orofacial strength and speech production disorders. By examining individual data, preliminary evidence emerges to suggest that speech, but not necessarily intelligibility, is likely to be impaired when lingual weakness is severe.
本研究比较了构音障碍成年人与神经功能正常(NN)的匹配对照组之间的口面部肌力。此外,还研究了口面部肌肉无力与构音障碍成年人言语障碍之间的潜在关系。
55名构音障碍成年人与55名NN成年人组成匹配组,在舌抬高、前伸和侧移以及颊齿和唇部压缩过程中,对着一个充气球产生最大压力(Pmax)。将这些口面部肌力测量结果与言语可懂度、言语感知评分、发音速率和快速音节重复率进行比较。
在所有任务中,构音障碍组的口面部肌力均显著低于NN组。舌肌力量与大多数言语缺陷评分呈中度相关,颊肌力量与言语缺陷评分呈弱相关。言语可懂度对构音障碍严重程度不敏感。前舌抬高Pmax严重降低(<18 kPa)的个体,句子可懂度正常至极重度受损(99%-6%),言语中度至重度受损(发音不精确率26%-94%;总体严重程度33%-94%)。
结果支持不同病因的构音障碍成年人存在口面部肌肉无力,但强化了口面部肌力与言语产生障碍之间的微弱联系。通过检查个体数据,初步证据表明,当舌肌无力严重时,言语可能会受损,但不一定是可懂度受损。