Chohan Muhammad Omar, Carlson Andrew P, Murray-Krezan Cristina, Taylor Christopher L, Yonas Howard
1Department of Neurosurgery,University of New Mexico Hospital,Albuquerque,New Mexico.
2Division of Epidemiology,Biostatistics, & Preventive Medicine,Department of Internal Medicine,University of New Mexico Health Sciences Center,Albuquerque,New Mexico.
Can J Neurol Sci. 2017 Jul;44(4):410-414. doi: 10.1017/cjn.2016.408.
The role of aggressive surgical manipulation with clot evacuation, arachnoid dissection, and papaverine-guided adventitial dissection of large vessels during ruptured aneurysm surgery in reducing vasospasm is controversial. Here we describe a single-institution experience in aneurysm surgery outcomes with and without aggressive surgery.
We performed retrospective analysis of all patients >18 years of age with subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) from anterior circulation aneurysms between 2008 and 2013 at the University of New Mexico Hospital. Vasospasm was characterized on days 3 through 14 after SAH based on: (1) angiography, (2) vasospasm requiring angiographic intervention, (3) development of delayed ischemic neurologic deficit (DIND), and (4) radiological appearance of new strokes.
Of 159 patients, 114 (71.6%) had "aggressive" and 45 (28.3%) had standard microsurgery. More than 60% of patients presented with a Hunt and Hess score of ≥3 and a Fisher grade (FG) of 4. Compared with standard surgery, there was a statistically significant decrease in the incidence of DIND in patients undergoing aggressive surgery (18.4% vs 37.8%, p=0.01). Moreover, there was a reduction in the number of new strokes by 30% in the aggressive surgery group with moderate or higher degrees of vasospasm (46.0% vs 76.5%, p=0.06). In the same group with FG 4 SAH, however, this difference was more than 50% (30% vs 64.7%, p=0.02).
We conclude that aggressive surgical manipulation during aneurysm surgery results in lower incidence of DIND and new strokes. This effect is most pronounced in patients with FG 4 SAH.
在破裂动脉瘤手术中,积极进行手术操作,包括清除血凝块、蛛网膜分离以及罂粟碱引导下的大血管外膜分离,对于减轻血管痉挛的作用存在争议。在此,我们描述了单中心关于动脉瘤手术采用积极手术与未采用积极手术的治疗结果的经验。
我们对2008年至2013年在新墨西哥大学医院因前循环动脉瘤导致蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)且年龄大于18岁的所有患者进行了回顾性分析。基于以下几点对SAH后第3至14天的血管痉挛进行特征描述:(1)血管造影;(2)需要血管造影干预的血管痉挛;(3)迟发性缺血性神经功能缺损(DIND)的发生;(4)新发卒中的影像学表现。
159例患者中,114例(71.6%)接受了“积极”手术,45例(28.3%)接受了标准显微手术。超过60%的患者Hunt和Hess评分≥3且Fisher分级(FG)为4级。与标准手术相比,接受积极手术的患者发生DIND的发生率有统计学显著降低(18.4%对37.8%,p = 0.01)。此外,在血管痉挛程度为中度或更高的积极手术组中,新发卒中数量减少了30%(46.0%对76.5%,p = 0.06)。然而,在FG为4级的SAH同一组中,这种差异超过50%(30%对64.7%,p = 0.02)。
我们得出结论,动脉瘤手术期间的积极手术操作可降低DIND和新发卒中的发生率。这种效果在FG为4级的SAH患者中最为明显。