Esposito Michael H, Lee Hedwig, Hicken Margret T, Porter Lauren C, Herting Jerald R
University of Washington, Seattle, USA.
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA.
Longit Life Course Stud. 2017;8(1):57-74. doi: 10.14301/llcs.v8i1.405.
A rapidly growing literature has documented the adverse social, economic and, recently, health impacts of experiencing incarceration in the United States. Despite the insights that this work has provided in consistently documenting the deleterious effects of incarceration, little is known about the specific timing of criminal justice contact and early health consequences during the transition from adolescence to adulthood-a critical period in the life course, particularly for the development of poor health. Previous literature on the role of incarceration has also been hampered by the difficulties of parsing out the influence that incarceration exerts on health from the social and economic confounding forces that are linked to both criminal justice contact and health. This paper addresses these two gaps in the literature by examining the association between incarceration and health in the United States during the transition to adulthood, and by using an analytic approach that better isolates the association of incarceration with health from the multitude of confounders which could be alternatively driving this association. In this endeavor, we make use of variable-rich data from The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (n = 10,785) and a non-parametric Bayesian machine learning technique- Bayesian Additive Regression Trees. Our results suggest that the experience of incarceration at this stage of the life course increases the probability of depression, adversely affects the perception of general health status, but has no effect on the probability of developing hypertension in early adulthood. These findings signal that incarceration in emerging adulthood is an important stressor that can have immediate implications for mental and general health in early adulthood, and may help to explain long lasting implications incarceration has for health across the life course.
越来越多的文献记录了在美国经历监禁所带来的负面社会、经济影响,以及最近出现的健康影响。尽管这项工作在持续记录监禁的有害影响方面提供了深刻见解,但对于从青春期到成年期过渡期间刑事司法接触的具体时间以及早期健康后果却知之甚少——这是生命历程中的一个关键时期,尤其对于健康状况不佳的发展而言。以往关于监禁作用的文献也受到了阻碍,难以从与刑事司法接触和健康都相关的社会和经济混杂因素中梳理出监禁对健康产生的影响。本文通过研究美国成年期过渡期间监禁与健康之间的关联,并采用一种能更好地将监禁与健康的关联从众多可能导致这种关联的混杂因素中分离出来的分析方法,来填补文献中的这两个空白。在这项工作中,我们利用了来自《青少年到成人健康全国纵向研究》(n = 10,785)的丰富变量数据以及一种非参数贝叶斯机器学习技术——贝叶斯加法回归树。我们的结果表明,在生命历程的这个阶段经历监禁会增加患抑郁症的概率,对总体健康状况的认知产生不利影响,但对成年早期患高血压的概率没有影响。这些发现表明,成年早期的监禁是一个重要的压力源,可能对成年早期的心理和总体健康产生直接影响,并且可能有助于解释监禁对整个生命历程健康的长期影响。